I agree. People gain and lose weight constantly. Someone earlier said she was "chubby" Please. I can't remember her ever looking "chubby", and personally I don't think she looks "skeletal".

You guys are all nut jobs. She's extremely hot.

That's what happens to vegetarians quite often. Someone give her a hamburger.
Never argue with an idiot. They drag you down to their level then beat you with experience.

I think she is ugly, can you imagine her in 20 years? she has no natural beauty ewwwwgggggggg!

This is months after the reply was posted, but I'm so angry, I must say something.
I assume, you, montmn are skinny as well? Or if you're a man, you're an anatomically correct Ken doll?
May I also assume that anyone who is above an ideal weight is fat?
Studies show that overweight people live longer than underweight, normal weight and obese people. People who are underweight AND extremely obese die the earliest, underweight being more likely to die.
From webmd.com:
In the newly published study, researchers used data from an ongoing Canadian national health survey to follow more than 11,000 adults from the mid-1990s to 2007.
Compared to people who fell into the normal-wei111cght category:

• Those classified as underweight were 73% more likely to die.
• Those classified as extremely obese with BMI of 35 or greater were 36% more likely to die.
• Those classified as obese with BMI 30-34.9 had about the same risk of death.
• Those classified as overweight with BMI 25-29.9 were 17% less likely to die.
  [http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20090625/study-overweight-people-live-longer]
  Although this doesn't mean she should be overweight, she could use to gain a few pounds so she's 73% more likely to live.
  So before you spout ignorance all over the place..Again..Think. Wouldn't you want Sarah Chalke to live longer and entertain us or look pretty in your opinion and leave her family behind in eventual death?

true she has always been a skinny girl. and to the douche who brings up skinny people dying, there are so many more fattys who drop dead. give up your BBW fantasies & live in the now. if a woman wants to look like a woman & not a bean bag chair, then let her.
Sarah Chalke has been & continues to be a stunning specimen of womanhood. she has always been slim never tubby.

http://www.imdb.com/media/rm608930304/nm0149950
she is too skinny in that photo too. Can someone please try to help her? I mean they even referenced her skinniness in Srubs.
There's nothing I like more, than a good old mass debate.

She is still adorable but I miss her when she was chubbier. And she certainly wasn't always skinny.
"An eye for an eye only ends up leaving the whole world blind" - Gandhiji

she was always skinny. i don't see what you guys are seeing.

i liked the nancy reagan comment. i was going to say she was the lost olsen "triplet".
anyway, she's hilarious and gorgeous, and therefore the perfect woman.
but yes, she's a bit too thin. as a friend of mine used to say someone get her a sandwich.

This message has been deleted.

is that a serious post? one of my close friends was in the hospital for months because she was too skinny. people have DIED because they were too underweight. a child dies every 7 seconds because they don't get enough food and are thus "too skinny." (and yes, that's a true fact)
so let's hope for the sake of your intelligence that you weren't serious.

u can never be to skinny! eh.

I think she is still pretty even if she is ridiculously skinny
and who cares either way her weight doesnt change who she is in any way
R.I.P. Adam

URL link:
http://www.themoreyouknow.com/Smoking/
(Apparently, she does NOT smoke.) But yes I agree. She HAS gotten skinnier and whinier, neither of which is an improvement.

i think shes super hot too, anyone know if shes a smoker though? ive noticed in a few eps her teeth were kind of discolored.. i hope she's not

I am watching "My Cookie Pants" and i just noticed that too. I came on here to see if anyone else noticed! ewww. Why can't people just stay at a normal weight!

This message has been deleted.

I've been noticing too.but in that episode in the Bahamas and she wears the bikini.oh my godI'd never thought I'd say this, but Jordan looked better in comparison (body wise) - she was just so damn skinny!!!
Oh well, I can understand though, the pressures of the industry and seeing yourself on television all the time

Yeah, I was wondering why her head was looking so huge but then I realised it's because she's dropped a lot of weight. It's sad to see what Hollywood does to young girls.

I liked her better when she didn't look this thin. She's so much hotter! Yay for the big b_ _ bs!

I'm glad that someone else has noticed this. She looks so very skinny now and that isn't an improvement. She needs to put back on a few pounds. Right now she looks almost emaciated.

I think she's still really cute. I like skinny girls. Even though I've always thought she was sexy and looked good.
She looks even better now. Although like Bill Lawrence mentions in the Scrubs DVD commentary that's more due to the fact that the show put more of an emphasis on her hotness after the first couple seasons. They even poke fun at this in a season 3 episode with Elliot compared to other female doctors.
In the first couple seasons the wardrobe and makeup people were instructed to make it realistic, in that new doctors tend to be short on sleep and relatively unkept, because of the high stress and long hours. Which is why Elliot looks far hotter from s3 on.

Yeah, she is too skinny right now and it really sucks. Evidence:<<
YIKES! I hadn't seen her this year and that was shocking. Somebody give that girl a cheesburger,QUICK! IMHO,she is one of the most naturally beautiful women on television,and her body BEFORE she lost all this weight was absolute perfection. She was absolutely smoking hot on all levels.
I remember one episode where somebody questioned if her breasts were real while standing off to the side with Carla and JD,and Carla said,"Yes,they are real.",to which JD replied,"and they are magnificent!" Even though I have never seen all of them,I could only agree.
Anybody think maybe she just got carried away with losing the baby weight,and will get back to normal?