Good looking gal. I'd totally **** her.
You've seen Guy Standeven in something because the man was in everything.

I think a flaw that can be picked out is that she's "pig-faced". She's still pretty though, and she makes the best of what she's got, but "pig-faced" non the less! She has a beautiful pig face! See what I mean http://cheezburger.com/2046423808

LMMFAO this woman is NOT attractive, her body is goofy looking, her face is homely, she walks weird, her facial expressions are weird. She is not attractive what so ever unless you like polygamists, cause that's what she looks like is a polygamist wife.

This message has been deleted.

Damage control in is ongoing by some hard working PR staff. Sad.

agreed! she's one of the most gorgeous women ever.

Are you crazy? I was unfortunately just forced to watch the Dark Knight and had to ask repeatedly, "Is she getting uglier throughout the movie or what?" I've never seen such a plain actress. And what about the botched nose-job? You don't count that as a flaw?

yep she is very beautiful

SHE LOOKS LIKE A SAD TURTLE.

This message has been deleted.

I noticed her too in Riding in Cars and wondered who is this pretty young actress? She looked so young on that role. Secretary and Sherrybaby made me a lifelong fan. She's superb and her looks make her stand apart from all the silicone barbies in Hollywood. And on top of that she can act!

All those women are beautiful. Also, I'll see your Streep, Ryder, Spacek, Moore and Seydoux and raise you Laura Dern, Amy Ryan (LOVE Amy Ryan), Lake Bell and Kate Micucci.

I always thought she had a beautiful face too. Just look at her expressive features, wonderful eyes and luminous smile:
https://s3.amazonaws.com/tribeca_cms_production/uploads/uploads/image/gallery_image/51cb4d03c07f5d2934000001/Gyllenhaal_Adaptation.jpg
The first time I saw her was in
Riding in Cars with Boys
. I thought to myself "now who is that?! She has such a striking face". Yet she was only in about 5 minutes of the film! Shows how far a good impression can go. Then
Secretary
came out and I became a real fan, have followed her work ever since.
People who call other people ugly, particularly when they clearly AREN'T ugly (as in Maggie's case), are usually just insecure about their own appearance. It's an ugly word. If you don't like the way a person looks, why make a huge song and dance about it? It doesn't effect you. Move on, and direct your energy to something you DO like.
I'm also glad she's not a supermodel type either. Because I find supermodels, both male and female, to be ridiculously boring looking. Maybe it's because modelling is such a vacuous and shallow career that I could never register enough interest in them to admire them. I think to be really beautiful, you have to be really different. Because difference becomes memorable. Look at Sissy Spacek, Meryl Streep, Winona Ryder, Julianne Moore, Lea Seydoux all unique and unconventional looking women, yet they have such incredible beauty. The beauty lies within the fact that they don't look like everybody else.

Maybe it's because I prefer quirky and cute over model-esque faces, or maybe it's because I am obsessive over character actors, which I think Maggie is, but I've always thought she was very attractive. I'm honestly surprised so many people find her so unappealing to the point where they're angry that she was cast in certain movies.
Reminds me of a Simpsons quote: Animals are a lot like people, Mrs. Simpson: some of them act badly because theyve had a hard life or have been mistreated. But, like people, some of them are just jerks.

more like a jigsaw puzzle

pffft. she's stunning. unique and gorgeous.

Time for that eye exam shaye22.