I'm neither one of those things and still thinks she ugly. Not attractive at all. She looks like a polygamists wife.

Google gylnhaal no makeup. Have your puke bucket ready just in case
my vote history:
http://www.imdb.com/user/ur13767631/ratings

This message has been deleted.

I don't think she's UGLY just only mildly attractive.
Did you see that article online yesterday that said a producer turned her down for a role as a romantic interest for a 55 year old because she was too old?
Perhaps she simply needs a better make-up artist. As she looks 45+ in her pictures.

So a 'gay' guy, by your reasoning, can't tell an attractive female from ugly? Sexuality, has nothing to do with what is 'aesthetically' pleasing and that in itself, is all subjective. Just because you find her 'physically' attractive, it doesn't mean that other 'heterosexual' males will. Gyllenhall, is not ugly either. She is 'average' looking, compared to many other women and that is coming from a 'gay' guy.

No anyone who calls out someone for being ugly is a perfect person .they look like Miranda Kerr or Jamie Dornan and have exquisite lives
They light up a room when they enter it and everyone thinks they are adorable
i'm being sarcastic

Guess I'll be joining you. Might as well have an orgy during the road trip while village people plays in the background.

This message has been deleted.

She looks like the baby that the devil was holding in its arms in the movie The passion of the Christ.

Uber ugly
Ugly on the outside and the inside
She is a hideous gorgon monster

wowim simply appalled at the insults i see here leveled towards this woman. and sorry to tell you..shes gorgeous, and has simply amazing eyeswhere anyone could get off saying shes ugly is beyond me. sorry she doesnt live up to your hollywood, paris hilton(who actually IS ugly as sin) type of standards
step up or shut up!!!

if I were attracted to insects, she'd be hot.

This message has been deleted.

One of the most retarded statements made on hereevery person has the same standard of beauty then ehhh?? That's sarcasm by the way..seriously though let's sweep silly topics like this under the rug and get on with it. And yes I said retarded.

This message has been deleted.

Hi Default:
Another explanation is that they have 2 digit IQ's. People who know very little are threatened by her views. They then lash out.
I hope that Maggie does not take their comments seriously.
R = f(B), where:
R = Reality, B = Belief

I'm a straight guy, and I don't think that she's all that bad looking. I actually think that she's kind of cute, when she's not all made up with red lips, etc.
I don't think that I've ever seen her in a movie, but from looking at pictures, it looks like she's got a pretty decent body too. And you have to love a girl who's so willing to get naked, as it seems she's apt to do.

This message has been deleted.

There is a fair chance you look like your avatar.

If you google "droopy face" her picture is the first thing that comes up. That's not even a joke. Do it. Her picture is
literally
the first image for that search.
Oh, and um, gay guys and ugly women are not the only ones turned off by faces that appear to be under 2X Earth's normal gravity.
Things are more moderner than before San Dimas High School football rules!

I'm a gay guy and I think she's ugly. Doesn't mean I cannot tell the difference between when I deem an unattractive woman and a beautiful woman. I think Eliza Dushku is so incredibly beautiful that if I was drunk enough I'd probably come on to her.
"Sunlight in the hair, and the blue sky fixed forever in your eyes."
The Vampire Lestat

Uhh, no. The logical explanation is that people have different ideas on what is beautiful and what isn't. It doesn't mean they're gay men or jealous ugly women. It means they think she's ugly.

I am a man and Maggie is such a amazing beauty in my ey1c84es. Her smile can be a reason for me to believe in heaven where I can enjoy that endless joy of seeing that pure beauty

She looks older than she is, she has no bone structure and no chin.
She isn't God awful ugly but she is below average.
She looks like Olive Oyl from Popeye.