BE IN THEM is my biggest beef. She's got some writing skills, but her directing skills are lacking and her "acting" skills? I've seen more talent in kindergarden plays.

You have a right to your opinion, but remember, there are a lot of us who like Miranda July and her work, and because of that she should be able to keep making films. You are not the only filmgoer in the universe.

Shouldn't you be posting on the Britney Spears message board or something?
Oh, wait. You are.

I'm with you. I seriously do not want to see this person, or anything she is involved with ever again. T2000he sad thing that she actually appeals to some pathetic little group of people who are the type of people who will go online into bulletin boards (such as this on IMDB) and start to tell EVERYONE that this girl is AMAZING in her acting & writing. ugh
I would say something like "I hope she dies tomorrow" because that is really how I feel - but I would never wish death upon anyone.

I'm sorry you don't think I'm "qualified" to express an opinion. After all, you certainly do know a lot about me.

This message has been deleted.

i don't think you are qualified to make that judgement.

Her writing is fantastic. Her film, howevernot so much. She doesn't quite understand the nature of the medium just yet. But she could certainly give it another try.

karochia eikit jus naxui lopetos. Nieko jus nesuprantat apie filmus, tai ir issipisinejat. Ech.. gaila, ot kaip tikrai gaila

V for Vendetta sucked ass.
All the movie did was try to get YOU to feel sorry for everyone excluding the "over-the-top" facist catholics. A good film? It was a total CheeseFest.
That film was for people who are easily moved emotionally.

I hated this film, too, but for a lot of different reasons. I hated it for the same reason I hate Miranda July's fiction-writing, and the directing and writing of a lot of other young artists out there. There seems to be this whole new trend of, how shall I put it, "cutesy"-ness, or, rather, effeminacy throughout the modern mediums of literature and film. Movies and fiction about the TRUE NATURE OF LOVE, or FINDING LOVE IN PLACES YOU WOULDN'T EXPECT, or SEEING THE INNER BEAUTY OF UGLY THINGS (including ugly people), or, worst of all, this whole big, get-you-tissue-box out concentration on CHILDREN, CHILDREN, CHILDREN, their innocence, their cuteness, their, gosh, remarkable insight.
And if you're about to accuse me of chauvinism or sexism, then let me tell you that this is coming from a gay teenaged male; one who lives under the stereotype of just thateffeminacy. Well, excuse me, but I like a movie with a little brawn, some real characters, difficult situations, and actual drama. Sofia Coppola, Todd Field, David Lynch, and Quentin Tarantino are some of my favorite directors. While not all of them make gruff, rough, masculine movies, their movies are also not weak-kneed, thin-skinned landfills of cloying filmmaking. The best movie of 2005, the year Me and You and Everyone We Know came out, was L'Enfant, followed by V for Vendetta, and then Million Dollar Baby. Now those are some real movies.

I must agree with the original post in at least one regard. I left watching this film thinking that it was like a rather lack-luster student film expanded to feature length. The cinematography bordered on incompetency at times.
Oh Lord, you gave them eyes but they cannot see

It's so obvious that Talented Rebel is just a bitter wannabe cancer ridden filmaker who has nothing better to do with his time but to bag on people who are actually doing it. Miranda July wrote, directed and starred in a feature film. That in itself is an amazing acomplishment. Keep on being a rebel manit's gotten you this far!

The story was too superficial. I know that it was trying to do the film school thing of questioning normalcy, but the story arcs never developed and were unsatisfying when they finished.
Exactly! I felt no real connection between her and the guy. It felt like the characters personalities weren't built up at all, and there were a lot of pointless scenes. I don't know. I didn't like the film.

I agree.
Someone related this movie to Garden State, but in that movie the characters were at least realistic and likeable. However, every character in this movie was unlikeable minus the little kid.
I usually like quirky, original films that focus on the absurdities of the real world. However, this movie knew that it was trying to do that and really became the worst version of itself.
The story was too superficial. I know that it was trying to do the film school thing of questioning normalcy, but the story arcs never developed and were unsatisfying when they finished.
At least I didn't waste the money, but I did waste the time seeing it . . .

Actually, Miranda July and her stupid movies bring the suck, pretty hard.

This has already been stated in all the other posts, but you bring the suck, pretty hard.
"Irony is the refuge of the educated" - Fugazi

This should be the last post on the topic of how the original poster of this topic missed out on enjoying a great film. Hope Miranda puts out something new soon.

no offense? but i really think you might be suffering from mental retardation.
good luck.

This message has been deleted.

This message has been deleted.

This message has been deleted.

This message has been deleted.

TalentedRebel wrote:
"the script was so dry, unemotional and just plain lame"
Naaah. My favorite quote for the moment, thanks to this movie, is beep you, beep me, beep the children, and beep peace!!" after she felt like she acted like an idiot in front of the guy she liked. I definitely identified with that moment.
And weird? Yes! Weird! Thankfully. Long live weird movies. I'm just glad there are alternatives to Jennifer Lopez movies out there. Does that make me weird? Yes. Ok. I'm definitely ok with that. Who the hell wants to be normal or like everybody else anyway?