Strongly agree with everything you said there.

DSOTM
The Wall is too bloated and self-indulgent. Also Alan Parsons’ engineering work on Dark Side is second to none.

The Dark Side of the Wall is my fave!
"Please vote to preserve the unique character of Warren…" - Robert Duvall

dsotm

Dark Side of the Moon.

for historical, cultural importance, music history, and artistic importance it's the dark side of the moon
lukejbarnett

The Wall. No contest.
Hark! Harold the angel sings.

The Wall, hands down.

Wish You Were Here

The Wall. It's the album that got me into Pink Floyd.
If i had my way, I'd have all of you shot.

but the power and effect on the listener is the 2nd most important thing and for that its the dark side of the moon.
last time i listened, really listened to the wall i was under impressed just not as impressed or moved as i was when i was listening to it as a kid. but the last time i really listened to the dark side of the moon i was as impressed and as moved by it as i was 20 years before listening to it.
the 1st most important thing is the technical side of the music. and for that its hands down the dark side of the moon.
lukejbarnett

There are 6 songs that stand out to me on DSoTM:
Money
Breathe (In the Air)
Time
Us and Them
Any Colour You Like
Brain Damage
And 14 on The Wall:
Comfortably Numb
Young Lust
Another Brick in The Wall pt.1
Another Brick in The Wall pt.2
The Happiest Days of Our Lives
Another Brick in The Wall pt.3
Hey You
In The Flesh?
In The Flesh
One of My Turns
Nobody Home
Goodbye Blue Sky
Mother
Run Like Hell
I'd say that there is less "filler" on DSoTM, but the overall body of work and number of good/great songs belongs to The Wall, and the concept of The Wall is a bit more complex and compelling. I also think 1973 was a better year for music than 1979, so The Wall really stood out as a great album from that year. So I'll go with The Wall.

I would take Wish you were here over both of them. But put me down for D.S.O.T.M. I suppose.

The Wall.
"Nobody is free, even the birds are chained to the sky" - Bob Dylan

The Wall

Animals

This message has been deleted.

BOTH.I JUST LIKED BOTH..I WISHD ROGER CAME SOME DAY TO FINLAND

Why choose at all? They are both phenomenal albums. I agree with the poster above.
Piper
is AMAZING! But I just can't choose between DSOTM or The Wall. My vote is split.
*Lilah
My vid pick for the day

Neither.
Piper at the Gates of Dawn blows all their other stuff out of the water, it's that bloody good.
The others I love still, but PATGOD is perfection.

Dark Side Of The Moon..it's my favorite album

Dark Side of the Moon

Neither.
Piper.
Or Ummugumma.

Dark Side of the Moon by far.
The Wall has too much Waters vocals and on repeat listenings hurts my ears, but luckily has about 50% excellent classics to go with the other half boring acoustic screechy Waters songs.
DSOTM is a true classic