immortals I've liked..
methos
fitz
darius
that guy from fine young cannibals
ramirez
connor
kurgan
i like to lean into how being immortal either makes you more civilized or more insane.

I knew who you were talking about. Just commenting on the nickname you gave him. I beleive everyone who knew him called him Fitz. But your name for him was appropriate because it sounded like a jokester name for sure. Fitz sounded too serious on a person like Fitzcarin.

Fitzy! Fitzcaire was in a lot of flashbackshe was always arguing with Mac about women and Mac saves his ass a lot..the guy who played him was I think Roger Daltry (from The Who) I loved him on the show! So funny! I only liked Amanda for a short time and then she just got on my nerves.
"It's not about right. It's not about wrong. It's about power."

Sorry to interrupt the rankings.
But to Backs silver. Fitzy???? I don't remember anyone calling him Fitzy. Maybe Amanda.
It's cute though. Nothing wrong with calling him Fitzy. Just teasing.

lauriolpla, I love your signature!
back to the topic at hand.
Richie was always my guy until later seasons, but then there was Methos.can I just say Yum, Yum, and Yum! I loved all the Methos eps and I was so glad they pulled him into the movies (however bad those movies were didn't matter)

1. Methos
2. Richie (R.I.P, I will always love you Richie Ryan!)
3. Mac
4. Fitzy! Man did I love Fitzy when they had all those flashbacks!
   "It's not about right. It's not about wrong. It's about power."

1. Methos
2. Duncan
3. Adam
   Peter Wingfield is hot as the wily "old" guy and the young student. His voice gives me chills. Love that accent.
   Adrian Paul is just hot. I remember taping his Victoria's Secret commercial back in the day. Oh, the days when I loved a man with long hair!
   Richie was a boy to me, even when I was younger than him.
   Ever have that feeling that someone is in the backseat RIP AU Misha Collins

I agree
Methos, Methos, Methos. Peter's performance made you want to forgive the whole Horseman thing. Also a man who has that crinkled smile, that wit, that intelligence.
He had me at the alternative is unthinkable!!
A far off second is Duncan solely because I enjoy dancing (actually I am a classically trained dancer) and seing him in Duende and Finale well a dancer would Love a partnering with Duncan.
3)Connor maybe. the eyes? It's intangible.

1. Methos!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2. Darius (yes I know he played a priest but still)
3. Connor (I lovvvvvve that laugh and those hypnotic eyes!)
   Richie never did it for me. I can appreciate Joe but never found myself attracted to him. Back in the day, I had a thing for Duncan but I outgrew thatMethos definitely helped with that
   Shan
   "A Friend is one before whom I can think aloud." ~~Ralph Waldo Emmerson

Methos
Methos
Methos
..
you get the point

I looooooove him. Because of him, I like big noses on dudes. Thank you Peter Wingfield.

Mine would be
Duncan
Methos
Joe
Fitz
richie

1. Methos
2. Duncan
3. Richie

METHOS - there can be only one
I like Joe but due to his age (compared to my own) he doesn't register as hot.
Neither Duncan nor Richie do anything for me.
I just loved the way METHOS looked in the Bronze Age (looked, not behaved), sizzling

My turn:
1.Methos
2.Fitz (how could you guys forget him?!)
2.Ritchie
"What would
I
want with
your
brain?"

My list:
Duncan
Methos
Joe
To me, Richie is cute and boyish, not manly and hot.

In my opinion, Richie was the best looking guy on the showMethos on the other hand, tall, scrawny, borderline albino, big nosewell those two guys are about like the two extremes in regards of good looking.

i used to like richie and duncan in that orderthen Methos turned up and they went out of the windowPW is far far hotter (and welsh like my hubby )
I am the ray of darkness in your otherwise sunny day

This message has been deleted.

My order:

1. Methos
2. Methos
3. Methos
   As far as I'm concerned, there can be only one! I got into the television series because I was a fan of Connor in the films. In the first couple of years of the show I never got into Duncan or Richie, and mostly watched for the sword fights. Then Methos showed up, and I was done for. Haven't paid attention to any of the other men in that universe since

Methos certainly is my favorite. I love the flawed hero, type of character.
For my 2 cents' worth, this is my order:
Methos
Joe Dawson. Jim looks great and he's got that voice
Connor
Duncan
Richie
"You can mistrust me less than you can mistrust him, mate. Trust me." Captain Jack Sparrow

Actually, I agree that Connor is hotter than Duncan. Taking the Highlander movies into account, my new order is:

1. Methos
2. Connor
3. Richie
4. Duncan

Wow. Tall, handsome, educated, cultured, decidedly un-macho, with a killer accent. Sold!
:)) Bought, and never regretted it for a moment!
Methos owes a lot to Peter, he was to last for just an episode and it was Peters great performance (along with his other talents, Im sure) that kept him alive after that.
I know Adrian and Stan have lots of fans but they dont do it for me. I was very disappointed when I found out Connor/Christophe Lambert wasnt going to be the centre of the TV series. Hes kind of strange but I like him, cant help but laugh every time he does.
So, my guys:

1. Methos/ Peter Wingfield
2. Connor/ Christophe Lambert
3. Hmmm not sure. Duncan/Adrian has a nice body but I dont really feel a click. Joe/ Jim Byrnes in spite of his handicap and ages a very handsome guy. So, its a draw.