Evi projects intelligence and her looks are liked by both men and women. It's no contest really.

Lilly gets my vote, they're both beauty's but Lilly was in my favourite show. Puts her up and what's Kate done a bunch of ridiculous vampire movies

Tough tough tough I'd say both too.
"Oh, I'm not gonna kill ya. I'm just gonna hurt ya, really, really, bad."

Beckinsale is superior in every way. She is classic beauty and ages really well unlike Lilly who's looking more and more like Hugo Weaving. Also, Beckinsale is a great actress who actually starred in real movies, unlike Lilly who can't act and only looks for SFX fluff because it isn't challenging. Finally, Beckinsale headlined her own franchise while Lilly's 36 and only playing some guy's feisty love interest over and over. Her filmography is the poorest of all actresses in that age group and younger.
Plus, that Wasp hair from Ant Man is so ugly on her. She looks awful with bangs and short hair.

Kate Beckinsale

Evi. (Tauriel) Elf warrior of Mirkwood (The Hobbit) - Master bow women, short and long blade expert. Attributes: Heightened Senses, Covert, Naturalistic, Agility.
Kate. (Selene) Vampire warrior (Underworld) - Proficient with many weapons, both medieval and modern. Attributes: Superhuman physical abilities, Agility and Speed.
I like Kate but Evangeline Lilly is my pick!

i'd have to say kate wins by looks, but after watching some interviews with evangeline i must say she's the most adorable human being i've ever seen, lol.
so as a complete package evangeline would definately get my vote. also she is exactly my age.. too bad our paths never crossed

I've recently discovered Lost and I'd have to say Evangeline gets my vote. She's so natural and pretty and fresh-faced.

This message has been deleted.

They're both very pretty, but I find evangeline sexier.
Kate Beckinsale:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_gx7OZdt7Uhs/TQ5BX6puq8I/AAAAAAAAFeo/e7LFUVIZ t3c/s1600/Kate%2BBeckinsale%2Bsmile.jpg
http://www.melrosejewelers.co.uk/rolex-watch-blog/wp-content/uploads/2 009/06/kate-beckinsale2-300x300.jpg
Evangeline Lilly:
http://www.howmuchdotheyweigh.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/Evangelin e-Lilly.jpg
http://cdn.everyjoe.com/files/2008/05/evangeline-lilly-nc.jpg

Kate Beckinsale is so much hotter and more beautiful.

Evangeline by far.
Kate Beckinsale had her face/nose/whoknowswhatelse done, Evangeline is a natural beauty.

This message has been deleted.

Kate Beckinsale for me
When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth

Kate Beckinsale by far and away. I think she's probably the most beautiful woman in the world. Evangeline is lovely to look at, but just pales in comparison to Kate, as does just about everyone else.

I had no idea who she was until I started watching Lost this week.
With that said, I guess I'm in the minority here when I say that I think Kate Beckinsale is average to me. I've never bought into the hype that surrounds this beauty that she has.
To each his/her own

I like Lilly a lot but its Kate Beckinsale hands down.. Shes the second most beautiful woman in the world imo.
Summer Glau can simply walk into Mordor..

Lilly has got my vote as well.
"I saw that movie on a plane and people still walked out." - Bill Hader (Sam Raimi birthday video)