Jeez, only 5? I'm just going to list my top 10 because I'm hella indecisive.
So, besides Elephant Man, I would say

1. Fox & the Hound
2. Titanic
3. Bicentennial Man
4. Finding Neverland
5. A Moment to Remember (a Korean Film that seriously made me sob)
6. Schindler's List
7. Life is Beautiful
8. The Painted Veil
9. I Am Sam
10. Legends of the Fall
    Seduce my mind and you can have my body,
    find my soul and I'm yours forever.

Big Fish!
The end where he tells his father how he's really going to die.
I've walked out of a room prior to that scene because other people were around.
It gets me every time.
Of course I didn't tell them why i left

The Pianist
Schindler's List
Hachiko
Philadelphia
Blood Diamond
Terminator 2 (the end of it)

The Elephant Man (1980)
is definitely the movie that made me cry the most (followed by
The Green Mile (1999)
), but the only movie I've watched enough times to be sure it'll always make me cry is
The Iron Giant (1999)
.
Don't listen to the negative ones; their arguments are irrational.

This message has been deleted.

Here's my list:
Rain Man
American History X (Third or fourth time I watched it - end scene)
Into The Wild
Armageddon (Cried in the cinema!)
Good Will Hunting (the "it's not your fault" scene, welling up now thinking about it)
127 Hours (the end scene, think the music got me) - I defy anybody to watch this film and not cry
Edward Scissorhands
I'm such a pu$$y :lol:

The Elephant Man
Titanic
Schindler's List
Hotel Rwanda
Terms of Endearment

Masquerade (2012)

The elephant man is definitely the saddest, I got goosebumps on couple of occasions and I was about to cry, but didn't Loved every bit of the movie. The movie for which cried so much was 'greenmile' & cried little bit for 'terms of endearment'

I'll be seeing this the soonest I can. Two that never fail to make me cry so far though are
MIRACLE IN CELL NO. 7
and
THE BOY IN THE STRIPED PYJAMAS
.
There's more to attraction than meets the eye.

It was touching but I didn't cry. Wasn't even close. I was angry at best.
I cry about Lion King, every time, and surely about many other Disney movies.
I don't make or have a list of cry movies.
But the most I cried when I watched The Impossible for the first and only time. Couldn't get a grip on myself.
Lincoln Lee: I lost a partner.
Peter Bishop: I lost a universe!

King of Masks (Bian Lian)
Story about a Chinese orphan girl.

Every film by Hayao Miyazaki.

I've only ever properly cried to one movie - Green Mile - but I had to fight back tears on quite a few. For example, What's eating Gilbert Grape, The Pianist, The Dallas Buyer's Club, Ray, Rain Man and Leaving Las Vegas are just a few big names which spring to mind.
I might also mention that I am too afraid to watch Her because I know I will cry uncontrollably.

I remember crying on 3 films, one was Elephant Man; during the scene where he breaks down upon meeting Mrs Treves. Next is Hachi: A Dogs Tale; truth be told, I haven't seen this film the whole way through but I cried when apparently Richard Gere's character had been dead for 10 years and the dog was still waiting for him. This next one is the least known of the three but this belongs at the end of a miniseries called Poor Little Rich Girl: The Barbara Hutton Story, if anyone knows a thing about what kind of life she led, you can guess from a number of scenes but the one that got me was when she was meeting Cary Grant while in her 60's with almost nothing left. Does that matter? No. They both make the most of the time they have together even though, by this point, they had lost their fame. It is genuinely hard to find a "happy moment" in that film but this one moved me to tears.
"I have always valued my lifelessness."

The Wizard of Oz used to make me cry, but I think I've seen it so many times now, I am immune. But I always have tissues handy when I'm watching a movie.
"Philadelphia" makes me cry every time.
And another Tom Hanks performance that was heart wrenching was the end of "Captain Phillips."
And to go farther back in time - "Love Story" and "Brian's Song" are real tear jerkers!

King of Masks

Nice lists even the ones mentioned.
Where's Bambi, Fox and The Hound, Wizard of Oz's Dorthy saying farewell scene, Neverending Story with the Artax scene etc.?
You killed Captain Clown, YOU KILLED CAPTAIN CLOWN-The Joker on Batman TAS

Pink Floyd The Wall

This message has been deleted.

There is no other movie I can think of that made me sob convulsively like this one. I viewed it again recently and luckily I was alone at the time and could let it all out. I've never wept so much during a film and don't believe I ever will.

One of only two films I've given a 10/10 to was The Elephant Man. (The other was 2001: A Space Odyssey.)
I will likely only ever watch this film once in my lifetime. It's impact was unmatched, and I've never felt so emotionally drained after watching a film. I don't ever want to see it again because my original experience with The Elephant Man was unparalleled, and I'd hate to diminish the impact it had in any way.
Nice guy? I don't give a sh_t. Good father? F_ck you! Go home and play with your kids.

I didn't cry and I'm actually surprised and disappointed with myself

This message has been deleted.