I did prefer Hoffman's version, though the Disney Hook is still great for a laugh.
So many stories, so little time.

Yeah I agree. Now in both cases they deliberately made Hook somewhat comedic so as not to scare children (which was their primary target audience), but I think they took it too far in the Disney version. Even as a kid I remember actually feeling somewhat sorry for that Hook because of how pathetic he actually was, and how Peter Pan actually took pleasure in tormenting him in some scenes actually made me dislike Pan to some degree. Perhaps I was taking it too serious, but either way I do think they could have made him a better villain in the Disney film.