I finally watched Tombstone and as much as I like the remake of 3:10 to Yuma (still haven't seen the original) I think Tombstone is the better film and I do not think it's as close as IMDB score indicates. Thanks to an incredible cast, and what should have been an Oscar nominated performance by Val Kilmer (I would have given him the statue over Tommy Lee Jones), Tombstone is one of the best westerns I've seen. Both are beautifully shot films with some of the most breathtaking scenery.
I would give 3:10 to Yuma 8/10, Tombstone 10/10.

Tombstone is better by far.

I liked 3:10 to Yuma, but Tombstone I can rewatch anytime.
So many stories, so little time.

Tombstone

Tombstone.

I think he is referring to the remake.
Without strife, your victory has no meaning.
Without strife, you do not advance.
Without strife, there is only stagnation.

Which version of 3.10 To Yuma? The original or the re-hash? I actually enjoyed Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the remake.

Love both, but I have to go with Tombstone.

3:10 isn't terrible but Tombstone is above it.

Of course, however the movie you chose to select that quote from is extremely mainstream. Don't be afraid to delve a bit deeper.

Lol Isn't a quote by its very nature, never original? Don't think too hard friendmight hurt yourself.

Nice top gun signature One would hope for a little more originality.

I see we've resorted to name calling. It appears the truth strikes a chord.
"I feel the need - the need for speed"
-Top Gun

Keke, you are a real fool. What a shame that is.

Settle down Maverick

I have to agree with leaps and bounds. The only thing that might have been comparable would be some of the acting, but even for the good parts in 3:10, Tombstone is still superior.
"I am on intimate terms with the desert"
Anyone know the reference?

Tombstone deez bro. Both ratings are in the general ballpark for what these two movies deserve. I think an appropriate argument can be made about which is superior, but "leaps and bounds"? I don't think so.
"I feel the need - the need for speed!"
-Top Gun

I personally thought 3:10 was a terrible movie. Tombstone was far and away a better movie.
Me too.
"3:10" was boring, imo. Comparing the two is like comparing a trip to 6 Flags to a trip to the dentist.
"Stick with me, baby, and you'll be fartin' thru silk."

I personally thought 3:10 was a terrible movie. Tombstone was far and away a better movie.
"I am on intimate terms with the desert"