Thinking of the Ep, Meant to be. S 5, Ep 4. Didn't they break up in that one too? Then in Snow Day S6, Ep 14, Amy is back again. Then between Snow Day and She is the one S7 Ep 9, Robert is on the dating scene again until S 7 Ep 14 he is proposing to Amy. My head is buzzing
SkiesAreBlue

Watching "What's with Robert" and Marie says, "That's the Third time!" Series 4, Ep 12. So if they get back together and then split again after this, that will be the fourth time.
SkiesAreBlue

Are you positive on that as I thought it seemed like they were on and off a lot

That was Robert Moves Back ( s3 ep25. They sort of broke up, she was so embarrassed regarding the sex escapade with the apartment block watching and then to be caught by Marie in Raymond's basement, I think she cooled things down a bit.
SkiesAreBlue

Thank you.
SkiesAreBlue

Season 4 -What's with Robert

If you're gonna pretend to cut her hair, at least put some scissors in your hand!

Which episode was the one Amy thought Robert was gay? Something to do with her birthday.
SkiesAreBlue

I just caught part of that episode where Amy broke up with Robert on her birthday. While she and Debra were talking I think they mentioned that was the third time they broke up. But I agree with you Wildstyle26, those three you listed are all I can recall.

I figured they were still dating off-screen. Because even when they were clearly together, you don't see Amy much, until season 7 when they're about to be married, and she becomes a regular.
It just seemed like a huge argument. Since the episode ends with Debra saying how good Amy is for Robert. Then there's the season 3 finale, after that episode. Once season 4 hits, Robert mentions he and Amy are together early in the season -"The Sister", which was the 6th episode into season 4 -had to check on the episode guide.

If you're gonna pretend to cut her hair, at least put some scissors in your hand!

What about the time that the building saw them have sex through the window?
We don't see her for quite a while after that episode, if I remember correctly. I thought they broke up off screen, but I could easily be mistaken.

I think that info is incorrect. After all, this is a site where anyone can post anything. Most online sites are this way. So you have to be careful of things posted with no source or references.
It helps when I list them for myself. The obvious ones

1. When he moves into his apartment
2. On Amy's birthday -thinking he may be gay
3. After Amy finds out about Stefania
   Now, it's a question of, did they count an extra event as a breakup that was not specified as one, or may not have been obvious as one.
   Like when Amy loses her virginity, and tells Marie off before she storms out in his pants. Maybe that counted, though I doubt it. So possibly a off-screen breakup I suppose. Or the writers just flubbed there.

If you're gonna pretend to cut her hair, at least put some scissors in your hand!