I prefer the killer in part one. Especially how crazy the killer was after the big reveal at the end.
I've been chasing grace/ But grace ain't easy to find

I liked the idea of the best friend being the killer, but Gayheart's acting was laughable and revenge motives are tired.
The professor in 2's motive was at least original, and the fencing mask was way better than the Kenny McCormick parka.

Brenda
The killer of 2 is forgettable
Death Awaits you (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

The Professor was actually believable as the killer.
Rebecca Gayheart probably weighs 110 pounds soak and wet. No way could she realistically pull off the stuff her character did in the first movie.
Also, the fencing mask, while not original, is much creepier than that stupid hooded jacket.

I prefer the killer in part 1.
Prostitute: What the beep are you doing?
Johnny: I'm gonna kill a bunch of people.

This message has been deleted.

Part 1, that's for sure.

I suspected Brenda as soon as she was like the only person who knew like all the urban legends. Notice in the beginning I think when there in a class and she like knows everything. Seemed a bit suss to me.

Brenda was much better killer in Urban Legend. Urban Legend when I watched it for the first time. I suspected Damon, Tosh and even The Dean up til they died! I thought Parker, Sasha too, The Janitor and even Freddy Krueger himself were the killer. I never thought Paul, Brenda or Reese were the killer. I saw them more as the victim like Natalie. I thought it was really Parker or Robert Englund! Even after they found his body in the back of Paul's truck. I thought he faking his death to fool Natalie and Brenda.

BRENDA!!! All the way.
I loved her lines. Funny as hell. Whoever wrote the dialogue for the scene where we figure her out is genius!
"I prefer the term, excentric. But yeahI guess you could say I'm a littlenutty."
"But lucky for you, miss THANG! I gotta visualaid"
"AwwDon't you wanna be an urban legend? All of your friends are, now."
I love that entire scene. Even if you don't like this movie and just take as another fluff slasher flick from the late 90s, you have to admit this scene was pretty sweet!
The other killer didn't have any interesting backstory whatsoever.
But yeah, Brenda Bates is the $h1t!

I like both flicks. I'd give the edge to the part 1 killer.

Brenda was the better killer, but however I did like the costume better in part 2

The Professor as a murderer was believable. Don't get me wrong, this movie sucks just as much as the first one, but at least him picking up and carrying around dead bodies is much more believable than a 100-110 ten pound college chick doing it.
Formally known as Coilector

This message has been deleted.

Brenda, hands down. Love her!
"Well, beep me pink with a hairy arse!" - Kitten from "Breakfast on Pluto"

most definitely (sp?) Brenda! i love the first UL.
~Nothin' I can say, a total eclipse of the
!
~

Brendaas far as being a psychopath goes, I think she had a more concrete motivebesides that, she was more creative, and her dirty work can definately be called horror.

I liked Brenda in Urban Legends as the killer, Professer Solimon was a rubbish killer, and he had a really rubbish reason as to kill all the poor film students.
Brenda had a better motive i think as she was much better at being a killer than professer Solimon.I liked Urban Legend more than Urban Legends - The Final Cut, because in my opinion i think the 2nd film lost the Urban Legends feel that was in the 1st film.
XxX Don't you just love that movie! Me and you have alot in common - Brenda (UL2) XxX

I knew it was Brenda, it was obvious to me, but my cousin thoguht it was Paul, but I had just seen I Know What You Did Last Summer, and in that movie they did the same thign as this one: they ahd a boy and a girl that fall for eachother, the girl tries to find out who the killer is and near the end they try to convince us the boy is the killer, so I knew he wasn't and that left one person: Brenda, so I knew it was her, Shannon still thought it was Paul, though
I wish
I
was someone's Heartsong

for me, Brenda was the ultimate killer, it was just her eccentresness and how badly she wanted to kill Natalie, and how mad she was, she had the serial killer look in her eyes. I know i didnt suspect her when u first watched the movie, i mean the only scene in when anyone could have suspected her was when she came back from seeing Paul and Natalie kissing, she looked pretty pissed there. But i never expected her, it kinda bent the rules by having a woman killer, i've only seen it twice (friday the 13th park one, and scream 2)
I thought the killer at first was Paul, but that was way to obvious. Then maybe two killers, obsessed with the legends; Sasha and Parker, but then maybe that creepy Janitor who i kept having my doubts about back and forth, but never really determining my feelings about him, but Brenda! that was awesome!

Brenda! (from part 1)
"It's UTP day" - Juvenile

Brenda
*** "Still on the bloody Island. Today I swallowed a bug." - Charlie ***

This message has been deleted.

This message has been deleted.