Jenna Lewis should rank very high after going into the final three with two people who were in love during
All-Stars
and who were both physically stronger than she was.

Even though he redeemed being a dumbass by winning later, I still put Tyson on the list. Thanks to his stupid move in HvV by not sticking with Boston Rob's plan to tie and take out Russell, we ended up being stuck with one of the worst Survivor seasons ever.

And chocolate. Don't forget the chocolate cookies.

They did it for peanut butter. Jenna Morasca went on to win that season.

Gratuitous nudity to impress Probst.
No trees killed in the sending of this message, but many electrons were terribly inconvenienced.

Two gals who were in the middle of an endurance challenge on a small podium, then dared each other to get naked, then did, then two seconds after jumped off anyway losing the challenge. Never understood wtf they were trying to achieve there.

Johnnie: Taylor was really not even playing survivor. He was playing "Bro, I'm on TV, hooking up with my Figs and being totally awesome."
LOL!
I agree.

He also dragged Figgy, Michelle (someone I think had potential), and maybe Jay down the tubes with him. Even thought I don't like Jay and he may be playing a little too hard, at least he is a serious player with his eye on the prize.

I totally agree. Taylor was not playing the game. He wasn't even trying. Who steals food, admits to it, and then steals more food? He wasn't into the game at all. He was just hanging out.

Taylor was really not even playing survivor. He was playing "Bro, I'm on TV, hooking up with my Figs and being totally awesome." I'd call him the biggest tool in survivor history. To qualify as a dumbass I think you have to actually be playing the game, just playing it badly. Like Eric, who was duped into giving away his idol and then voted out, or James, who was voted out with two idols.

James has only 1 one individual reward challenge and no individual immunity challenges over 3 seasons played. What makes you think he had a "strong chance" of winning 1 of the next 3?

That guy who gave his idol away at tribal, then they voted him out.
Erik
Or James, who was voted out with two idols in his pocket.
That's where my vote goes. He had two idols and everyone knew it and there were just three tribals left where he could use them. Plus, he had a good chance of winning individual immunity any of those weeks, ensuing a free ride to the final four. There was a 99% chance of making it.
What Would Jesus Do For A Klondike Bar (WWJDFAKB)?

That guy who gave his idol away at tribal, then they voted him out. Or James, who was voted out with two idols in his pocket. Taylor's up there.

Keith "stick to the plan" Nale?
Taylor is in the upper echelon of dumbasses. He crossed over from terrible player to really REALLY terrible player, and I love him for it. Sad he's gone.

the guy who ruined reed's plan at tribal in san juan del sur. can't remember his name
sag winner naomi watts
3 time golden globe nominee and emmy nominated director beyonce knowles