CRAZY/BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Heath Ledger Come Back,
This isn't funny, at all.

They were both a little gut wrenching. But I pick a walk to remember
www.fictionpress.com/~synd
www.fanfiction.net/~synd

This message has been deleted.

Crazy/Beautiful.
A Walk To Remember was ok.
R.I.P Paul Walker 1973-2013

I too would vote hands down on C/B. I approached AWTR with an open mind but it didn't work for me. It was a completely different film. It didn't have that realistic, off-beat quality that I love so much in C/B. It just looked like all those other films with sad endings and preachy, unnatural script.

Definitely Crazy/Beautiful! Far more depth and plot and way better acting! I agree that A Walk to Remember was very preachy, gushy, improbable and just too sentimental for words. I didn't like it one bit. I have never liked a Nicolas Sparks' adaptation [or novel for that matter]. Just too soppy.

I didn't like A Walk To Remember. A bit self-righteous and preachy.

I lik both but A Walk To Remember is much better than Crazy/Beautiful.

What does A Walk To Remember have to do with this movie? This is almost a direct remake of Mad Love. In that case this movie, because it has a happier ending, wins out. A Walk To Remember and this movie cannot even be compared.

Anyone that pretends to use British slang, while obviously not a Brit is just a moron.
Plus, your British spelling comes and goes, it seems, when you know which words have a British spelling.
Don't be a phony.

I didn't like A Walk To Remember that much either, so my obvious choice shall be Crazy/beautiful. I just love this movie!

I think Crazy/Beautiful is more realistic, so I'll have to go with that one. It's really one of my favourite movies. I didn't like A Walk To Remember that much, I thought it was going to be better.. The Notebook, written by the same author as A Walk To Remember, is a thousand times better!

Okey I saw Crazy/Beautiful and its very good. good acting chops by both Dunst and Hernandez. However, between A Walk To Remember and Crazy Beautiful I think I don't have to choose because they are both great.
"This is where they DIE!!!

crazy/beautiful is more like the girl next door or mad love then anything. a walk to remember is way out of its league, so much better. 50 years from now if you watch both movies a walk to remember is much more watchable and deep and beautiful. a walk to remember is a movie you watch when you grow old with your loved one it's just so beautiful.

Never Seen Crazy Beautiful but i think its going to be a good movie. I'm going to watch it one of these days however A Walk To Remember is a very excellent movie which is truly worth remembering.
"This is where they DIE!!!

Anyone who chooses A Walk TO Remember can't be taken seriously

AngelCake56FJS:
Im sorry Sir/Mam but you are an absolute pillock!
Whoever and i mean WHOEVER thinks Walk to remember is not a good film is just a moron. And i mean it. A story of Love and you make a comment like that?
One of the few films that i will never forget. A Love that exists within us all. I have never seen Crazy/beautiful but i am SURE i will pick A walk to remember as my favourite.

A Walk To Remeber is some sappy load of $hit!!!!!!!!

both are good but Crazy/Beautiful is better

Crazy/Beautiful hands down!!! It has a lot more depth, and better acting. The movie was solid. AWTR was good but a bit too contrived.

I agree both are very watchable films.But Kirsten Dunst & Jay Hernandez take the acting honors over the very underated Mandy Moore & that unknown dude of " A Walk to Remember"
Late

Crazy/Beautiful without hesitation
Simple - better cast, better director, better storyline
There is a lot more depth.
Christina xx

I couldn't choose. They're both great in different ways. It's like you can't compare apples to oranges

i agree both movies r really good, but i'd have to choose A Walk To Remember too