I agree! From the music of Arvo Part, Mazzy Star and the song at the beginning..the scenery, as well as the love story behind it, there was a great deal to love about this movie. I think that people hate Madonna! I think that's it. And while I thought her acting in this was a bit childish, she had some good moments. As I stated before, if Jennifer Aniston had starred in it, or Cameron Diaz, most would have loved this. I think it still would have gone straight to video, but it wouldn't have been so rigidly and unfairly reviewed.
The lead actor is a predominantly Italian actor. How many of us could not only act out a love scene in front of someone's director/spouse, but also do it in another language? Not too many. Giannini was great. Full stop!

Glad somebody else on here felt a similar way as i did when watching it.
I got it for a 1 from a local second hand dvd store and i watched it through and i really liked the first 25 minutes or so,i did kind of feel somewhat uncomfortable with the whole slapping her around in the middle section , and i actually found the ending quite moving, i guess the music added to the scene, spiegel im spiegel by Arvo Part.
I am a Madonna fan, but not the kind of fan who has to say everything she has done is incredible, because she has done the odd thing where ive thought " hmmmm " but i actually thought the film was not that bad at all.
" the dreams of youth, are the regrets of maturity " Legend

"this is a decent flick with a few great moments"
I totally agree.

Our control freak has already deleted it. But check this out:
http://www.imdb.com/board/20000659/board/nest/121073639?d=121835709#12 1835709
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by gbennett5 1 day ago (Sun Nov 2 2008 21:53:08) Ignore this User | Report Abuse
UPDATED Sun Nov 2 2008 21:55:47
What you're "missing" is that Simon was/is a pop-rock singer, Streisand
is a vocalist. Streisand has done pop-rock singing of course - singing
ON THE BEAT - and Simon has dabbled in standards. And not too successfully.
As for Vanity's "civility" comment, that was due to your "blowing it"
jab. You don't need to be so rude, do you? And please stop requesting
my presence here by posting on other boards - it's inappropirate to the
other posters.
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by jimellis 1 day ago (Mon Nov 3 2008 01:55:27) Ignore this User | Report Abuse
UPDATED Mon Nov 3 2008 02:04:35
"and please stop requesting
my presence here by posting on other boards - it's inappropirate to the
other posters. "
well,la-de-da.. I am being 'inappropirate" to viewers because I uttered your name on another board? You are ridiculous and pompous,and a phony.
I posted your name ONE time; did the 'viewers say they were devastated by it
If you had given me an articulate reply instead of glossing over, I never would of been rude. You don't have to reply to a thread but if you do,don't minimize it.

MY question was why Simon and her ex,James Taylor use no vibrato,and why Simon sounds off-key. Your reply has nothing to do with my question.
It's not about who sings the "standards" or the the "pop" songs,etc.
If you don't know,Mr. Expert, move on to the next thread.
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by gbennett5 20 hours ago (Mon Nov 3 2008 08:22:18) Ignore this User | Report Abuse
You're rude and you know it. Now kindly GET LOST.
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by jimellis 15 hours ago (Mon Nov 3 2008 13:37:49) Ignore this User | Report Abuse
really? anyone who calls you on your pretentious attitude is "rude",hmm?
Just like Craigard was was rude too?
You bring the rudeness out in peoplenoticed the trend?
Just accept it.
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by MoonsofJupiter 14 hours ago (Mon Nov 3 2008 15:05:16)
gbennet, you're talking to a brick wall. I and several other posters have been the victims of this control-freak's rude comments. He usually deletes people he disagrees with (which is almost everyone). My advice is to put the guy on ignore. He really is beyond talking to.
Re: question: Why can't I stand the Celine Dion/Streisand high pitch?
by gbennett5 5 hours ago (Mon Nov 3 2008 23:18:49) Ignore this User | Report Abuse
And he's extremely peculiar. I have previously enjoyed discussing
Streisand, but when he "paged" me by POSTING on another board, I thought
that was pretty strange. But then I get attacked when I state my
opinion on the difference between Carly Simon and Streisand (and I like
both singers). Yes, I will be ignoring this moron in the future and
I appreciate your support.

This message has been deleted.

Say there, Ideali, how ya doing?
My thoughts exactly. $4.50????????????? They saw him coming.

This message has been deleted.