X3 was so bad it made this movie like a master piece. But on a later re-watch people realize it wasn't good.
That is not correct. Superman Returns was excellent
You're from the future?Well that's brilliant!Do they still have sandwiches there?

Unfortunately the only good thing in this flick is superman himself (not even the acting, just the character), and somehow that was enough for them. They were able to overlook how stupid the unfunny comedy was, how weak and lame the villain was, how bland Lois Lane became, etc for whatever reasons. I dunno how they did it, but maybe they were off base because this movie has not aged well at all.

Critics liked it because it sucked Donner's dick.

1. BVS 2. TWS 3. Avenger

I heard many prefers routhe came back after MOS and bvs . Cavill tho looks the role that's really it. He's very miscast where routhe had some of the Clarke and superman traits . Reason why so many like super girls superman . It was nice to see superman being superman again. Not being depressed and moping .

Most of those aren't real personality traits

"Describe Lois and superman in this film without doing the followingtaking the comics into account, saying their professions. You also cannot describe their relationship or their role in the film "
You have to discuss both their relationship and their role in said-film - roles and relationships are what defines characters.
Lois - a little embittered by having been left with no explanation yet conflicted about Superman, inquisitive, working mom, perky, resilient, heroic
EDIT: regretful later for
writing that article
Clark/Superman - trying to deal with the consequences of having left Earth and come to terms with its changes (regretful), questioning his own relevancy and place within it, contemplative, a little jealous of Richard, klutzy (as Clark), larger than life, heroic and assuring (as Superman), conscious of his surroundings and those around him, resilient - has a bit of humor/playfulness (ie
the look he gives the gunman after being shot in the eye
)
"one is a stalker and the other is a whore"
That is so waaay off base it's not funny. He wasn't "stalking" Lois - when he went to her house, it was to talk with her as Superman after being cut off by her as Clark. Unfortunately, when he appeared, Richard and Lois were having a conversation about him and the possibility of her still having feelings for him. "Whore"? She wasn't sleeping with the entire city after Superman left her. Again, an incredibly unfair and inaccurate summation.

Unlikable

Describe Lois and superman in this film without doing the followingtaking the comics into account, saying their professions. You also cannot describe their relationship or their role in the filmnot only are they without personality traits but they are unkillableone is a stalker and the other is a whore

"The characters were beep hollow"
How so? What makes them hollow?
"Brandon route can't act his way out of a paper bag to save his life and has zero personality"
Brandon Routh was fine as Superman.

The characters were beep hollow and their motivations are like BVS nonexistent lifeless and dull. Brandon route can't act his way out of a paper bag to save his life and has zero personality

Nice try. Critics liked the film because they didn't watch it with the baggage that most people had while seeing it.
The critics praised that the film was more than a "Rock em sock em" action movie but instead focused on the characters and their motivations.