They were both awesome after I actually paid attention to the Force Awakens.

Nay, I fell asleep halfway through.
Play with monkeys, put bananas in hidden places

I don't like Star Wars, period. Ads for Rogue One in particular make it look like a ripoff of Hunger Games, with that picture of a Katniss-Everdeen-wannabe.

I liked them both.
They each had different purpose.
I thought the story in TFA was underwhelming and really just a rehash of ANH, but everything else was great.
RO was a good movie with forgettable characters.
In short they both have + and - which IMO balanced each other out.
"I care about the law. It's justice I don't give a toss about."
Cleaver Greene

This message has been deleted.

Yay!!!

Yay, Rogue one has way more depth and originality than that garbage Mary Sue TFA

Yay, except for Daisy Ridley, she was the gem of that film.

The studio actually
sort of
recommended the ending.
It's what the writers wanted to do. But they were doubtful they'd be allowed so they didn't include it in the script.
But then when the studio read it the execs were like "so they all have to die, right?"
Most people thought I was a hero for killing Lydia's parrot.

Good question.
I think Rogue One was much better written and had a more solid story that made sense. But, the characters were largely bland, dull and forgettable. The best parts of the movie were throwbacks to the originals; Vader, Tarkin, etc.
TFA had a lazy story that basically re-hashed the original, and the writing was typical JJ Abrams bad. But the characters were good and had chemistry, and I enjoyed watching them.
So I guess Rogue One has the better plot and writing, but TFA had more entertaining characters.
Overall I'd say I preferred Rogue One, though.
Whores will have their trinkets.

I saw it for the first time yesterday and I liked it. I was not expecting that ending, especially with a Disney Star Wars film.
'Honi soit qui mal y pense'

yay.
it's Star Wars' "Last Flight of the Osiris". it's sad but a story good enough to be told without the needing to eat 'member berries
Sean Bean has not died from Lightsaber related issues yetjust saying

Nay.
Wouldst thou like the taste of butter? A pretty dress? Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?

Yay, every main should always end like this.

"Art is magic delivered from the lie of being truth"