Constance.
If you love Jesus Lizard and are 100% proud of it, copy this and make it your signature!

Lydia reminded me of Sarah Palin or the main character in the movie Fargo. I really dislike that archetype.
Am I using that word right? archetype?

Luckily I love them both for different reasons..
Jane Lynch did steal every scene she was in though. That's for damn sure.
But Lydia just cracks me the beep up sometimes.

I prefer Mullally's Lydia to Lynch's Constancebut I will say that Constance helped me enjoy Ryan Hansen's character Kyle more.
Even the most primitive society has an innate respect for the insane.

Jane Lynch as Constance.

Constance. Constance all the fcking way.

I think there was kind of a running joke involving Lynch and the blonde actor, that they were both bad actors and looked alike and I missed their interactions in the second season. Mullaly is all eyeballs and eyebrows for comedy(wha-wha-what????) and thought Lynch was per unusual a favorite. Also a one-for-one switch for middle aged actresses afer the glee loss wasn't quite moving

This is one of the things I disagree most on with my friend who also loves this show. Overall, I think Megan Mullaly was funnier, both as a character and as an actress. All of her "my friend Peg" lines make me laugh embarrassingly hard.

I am much more of a Megan Mullally than a Jane Lynch fan and I have to say, I preferred Constance. Lydia, to me, was just kind of cute but boring. Lynch can be grating/annoying at times but her character had funnier lines. Coolidge was great just like she wasin small doses.
I am a French bitch

I thought Lydia was much better/funnier than Constance. And I'm a Jane Lynch fan. She just didn't seem right in this show to me and honestly as horrible as this sounds I couldn't tell at first whether she was supposed to be mentally challenged or just kind of stupid or what.
I love Lydia and the running joke where she thinks various people are celebs when they aren't or she thinks certain celebs are someone else (Guttenberg/Danson, etc). I enjoy how happy and silly she is all the time.
"Rock 'n roll martian!"

I think Jennifer Coolidge was funnier than both. But I think Lynch was a lot funnier than Mullally. Lydia just felt Forced and kind of annoying to me.
Put your lighter in the air and lead me back home.

They are all good. Too bad Coolidge's visit on the show was so brief. I wish she had been a regular.

I have to say I much prefer Lynch. I quite like Mullaly in what I've seen of her in other shows such as Parks and Rec, but I felt her character in this was pretty annoying.

All three are very unique, which is a big testament to both the writing and acting. Lynch nails almost every line in Season 1, however.

Jennifer Coolidge.

This message has been deleted.

megan mullally was better
http://www.youtube.com/theboftheads

Lynch owned the first season. Every line she had was brilliant.

Lydia is just uncomfortable to watch, which may have enticed certain viewers and repelled others. I think she's polarizing. When Constance came back, I realized how much I missed that sort of character. Someone who was ridiculous, but still motherly and could provide some sort of comfort to other characters. Lydia was the complete opposite of this, which I suppose the writers thought would be interesting to try out.

Megan is far superior, but Jane Lynch starts to grate afetr a while as shes not really that good in my opinion
we don't need no education
yes you do, you've just used a double negative

Lydia gets a lot of hate, but I actually liked her. Her brainstorming with 'Wesley Snipes' was hilarious.
You're the funniest thing I seen since Biter chewed off that Septa's teats - Rorge