I thought it would be some type of wildlife, just didn't expect it to be frogs. Most people don't know what sounds wild animals make, even ones they may think they are familiar with. The wilderness can be home to some really blood curdling noises in the dark. I expected it to be some kind of birds personally. I think this was a good narrative decision though, they want to keep it always up in the air if its supernatural or just psychological so they can never fully confirm one or the other.
Cast In The Name Of God…Ye Not Guilty

It jumped the shark in episode 3 of season 1.
If you can’t say something nice, say something clever but devastating.

I've watched the last two episodes half arsed so I've missed some bits but I was lmao at those 3. Then lottie outta nowhere
🤍

I dug the first season so hard that when season two came along I had theories and all sorts of interest but it unfortunately just never clicked for me.
Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange
A walk-on part in the war for a lead role in a cage?

I did yes but there was a long wait for S3 and I lost interest.
You stupid fuckers, you know who you are.

Did you like the other 2 seasons?
Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange
A walk-on part in the war for a lead role in a cage?

I watched the first episode of S3 then forgot about it forever.
You stupid fuckers, you know who you are.

My password is password.

it jumped during season 2
Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange
A walk-on part in the war for a lead role in a cage?

I think the whole point is to leave an air of mystery around the events, is it supernatural, is it completely explainable, we are not supposed to have a concrete answer and I don't think they will 100% answer it even in the end. I do think it is most likely that it is all psychological and not supernatural but I think the creators are never going to fully rule out the possibility of something more.
Cast In The Name Of God…Ye Not Guilty

^^ hasn't watched or can't comprehend season 1, dum dum
My password is password.

1. More blood is required. The demon is not yet pleased
2. Hysteric over what? The adult storyline is dumb. They’re all annoying adults and hysteric.
   Stop.

1. Van is coughing blood, not healed
2. They've been reduced to "hysterical girls"
   My password is password.

Did you want it to be supernatural?
This is better. The noise isn’t the frogs. Well it literally is, but what the girls are hearing is the projection of their own fear and primitive aggressions onto the noise these frogs make. Mass hysteria that’s brought out the evil lurking in all of us.
They can still deploy the supernatural. It’s implied through the apparent healing powers their “sacrifices” generate.
Stop.

Even the frogs are getting copious pussy? Fugazi is ****ed.
My password is password.