I just watched Stranger Tides again yesterday. I must be the only one who loved Stranger Tides because it didn't have the stupid love story in it between Will and Elizabeth. I loathed them both.

1. Stranger Tides
2. Curse of the Black Pearl
3. Dead Man's Chest
4. At World's End

Curse of the Black Pearl (DUH) 10/10
On Stranger Tides 8/10
Dead Mans Chest 7/10
At Worlds End 6/10

1. Dead Man's Chest ( The first view of Kraken, Black Pearl ship is totaly destroyed )
2. Curse of the Black Pearl ( I love Orlando and JD act, and Keira is georgeous here )
3. At World's End ( The beautiful mermaids )
4. On Stranger Tides ( Slow pace at the beginning )

1. The Curse of the Black Pearl
2. At World's End
3. Dead Man's Chest
4. On Stranger Tides

1. The Curse of the Black Pearl
2. Dead Man's Chest
3. At World's End
4. On Stranger Tides
   War, what is it good for?

Basically in order of release:

1. The Curse of the Black Pearl
2. Dead Man's Chest
3. At World's End
4. On Stranger Tides

Black Pearl- 10/10
Dead Man's Chest- 9/10
On Stranger Tides- 8/10
At World's End- 8/10
"Martyr me for Cordis Die."

Dead Man's Chest 10/10
At World's End 9/10
Curse of the Black Pearl 9/10
On Stranger Tides 8/10

1. Curse of the Black Pearl
2. At World's End
3. Dead Man's Chest
4. On Stranger Tides
   History is written by the victor. History is full of liars.

1. Black Pearl, because it was so new and so surprisingly good. I mean, what was the idea here - Disney making a movie based on one of their rides? And pirate movies had been doing badly for decades. (See, for example, Cutthroat Island.) But a perfect role for Depp and a nice little side story with Knightley and Bloom.
2. Dead Man's Chest - a good expansion that expanded the Pirates theme without becoming bloated. Bill Nighy as Davy Jones is great.
3. Stranger Tides - the film missed Knightley and Bloom. Also, it was noticeably done on a much smaller budget than the previous two. Most of the climactic scenes set in Florida were obviously done on a sound stage. But the additions of Cruz and McShane are great. The plot is a bit of a mess, but the dialogue is filled with first-class zingers.
4. World's End. Series became a bit too bloated. Spent way too much time with Jack in the land of the dead. Still had some good moments, but it's the classic problem of a series that's gotten too large and wants to keep all the characters from previous films while introducing new characters.

1. Dead Man's Chest
2. At World's End
3. Curse of the Black Pearl
4. On Stranger Tides

1.On Stranger Tides
2.At World's End
3.Dead Man's Chest
4.The Curse of the Black Pearl

1. The Curse of the Black Pearl (Mostly for Depp and Rush)
2. On Stranger Tides (Depp gets his own movie! Yay! + Rush and Cruz)
3. Dead Man's Chest
4. At World's End

1. The Curse of the Black Pearl
2. Dead Man's Chest
3. At World's End
4. On Stranger Tides
   They get worse every time they release one.

1. Curse of the Black Pearl
2. Watching a Black Pearl roll down a street
3. Watching a Black Pearl do nothing
4. Several chunks of cow dung in a blender
5. Dead Man's Chest
6. AIDS
7. Leprechaun VII
8. Johnny Depp pooing in a blender
9. A PC BLue Screen of Death
10. Doctor Zhivago converted to 3D
11. The other seven Pirates Movies
    Yeah, think that about covers it

1.Curse of the Black Pearl
2.On Stranger Tides
3.Dead Man's Chest
4.At World's End

1. Curse of the Black Pearl
2. On Stranger's Tides
   The other two don't even make the cut
   "If you do not enter the tiger's cave, you will not catch its cub"

My list is based by watching the movies many times.

1. Dead Man's Chest
2. At World's End
3. Curse of the Black Pearl
   0 On Stranger Tides. Not a place worthy (so bad, it makes me sad..)

1. Dead Man's Chest 8/10
2. Curse of the Black Pearl 8/10
3. At World's End 7/10
4. On Stranger Tides 2/10 (So bad that I refuse to even acknowledge it as part of the POTC franchise, instead let's just pretend it was a very bad dream that we all collectively saw and now its over)

1= Curse of the Black Pearl
2= On Stranger Tides
3= Dead Man's Chest
4= At World's End

1. Dead Man's Chest 9/10
2. The Curse of the Black Pearl 9/10
3. At World's End 8/10
4. On Stranger Tides 7/10

1. Dead Man's Chest
2. Curse of the Black Pearl
3. On Stranger Tides
4. At World's End
   ALTOBELLO YOU beep!!

Curse of the Black Pearl
On Stranger Tides
At World's End
Dead Man's Chest
Lol I must have completely different tastes then everybody else

1. Curse of the Black Pearl 9/10
2. Dead Man's Chest 8/10
3. On Stranger Tides 8/10
4. At World's End 7/10