I like to make small critters explode by shooting them with the buffalo rifle.
Who can take you higher than a twin peak mountain
blue
?

Ive done some really sick things in this game, like killing Abigail, Jack and Uncle by throwing dynamite at them.
Also, when hunting buffalo, I throw a stick of dynamite into a herd to kill as many of them as I can.
"But dont you forget Captain, for the record; Im stone cold sober!"

This message has been deleted.

Ok that guy who calls you a chicken head and dares you to a drawl? i blew his balls off with a shotgun.

Killing my own horse is how I make my entrance. Full sprint, then blam, right in the head and it lies dead in front of the saloon.

Well so far going onto the farm next to Bonnie Mcfarlands and slaughtering all their cows for their skin.
Also killing your own horse.

I can never get the animals to eat or kill people. It's annoying.

I once took a hogtied woman to Rio Bravo, covered her in bait and then watched from a safe distance as a pack of hungry Cougars clawed her to death.

tonight i killed someone by accident in red dead redemption, i was in theives landing in my home, first i shot out my light (since there's no light switch that i've seen) and i decided to open a window by shooting at it with my shotgun (since i don't use it much) and i somehow tookout a lantern that was on a building a cross the dirt street from my home and it set someone on fire (because i kept hearing their screams as they died) and i had john marston go outside and i saw the fire die out.

This message has been deleted.

I dragged some guy behind my horse near some cliffs, then I turned my horse so it was running by the cliff face and let go of the lasso. The guy just flew off the cliff!
Who can take you higher than a twin peak mountain
blue
?

I ran over a nun once and lost 50 honor for it lol.
Z҉A҉L҉G҉O̚̕̚
HȄ̐ IS COMI҉NG >

my most recent acts of cruelty, the first one was weird, i was in armadillo and i walked up behind a cowboy who was on a horse and he turned around in his saddle and pulled out his six shooter and shot at me, so i pulled out my rifle and shot and killed him. the second one was in benedict pass i was there to use my pardon to take care of a bounty that was on my head after that i went into house and i did a stealth kill on a man who was a sleep in bed (i slit his throat) and what happened after i left that house was funny, i saw a cowboy enter it so i followed him in and when he saw the dead body was funny he just acted like it was nothing new and just yawned and turned around and left the house, my third one was cruel i was about to cross the rio grande into mexico when i saw a man at a camp i lassoed him and hog tied him and put him on my horse and i rode to the rio grande and threw him in and let him drown, after he drowned i shot him in the back.

This message has been deleted.

I did the obligatory train squashing, but the worst thing I ever did (twice) was, going to Las Hermanas, approaching a nun sleeping in a bed, taking out my knife, just before a prompt came up on screen. "O for Stealth Kill". Yep, I slit the throat of a sleeping nun.
An idiot: Someone who thinks Hitchcock is an STD.

well my newest act of cruelty made my previous one look tame, i roped and hog tied a cowboy and took him aways out of armadillo and laid him on a streach of railroad tracks and waited for a train to come and watched him get turned into ground beef.

I killed both Jack and Abigail.
You can't directly aim at them, but if you use your shotgun, and aim directly next to them, the shell will still hit a little. I stood outside Jack's window while he laid in bed reading, pointed my gun near his face, shot, he didn't die, instead got up and ran around the house screaming, but there was blood all over his pillow. Testing out if he could actually die, I finished the job inside the house before they made me restart from my last save point.
With Abigail, I shot at her while she was cooking dinnner, she ran out of the house screaming and kept running and running just crying and screaming. It kind of reminded me like a horror movie scene. I just ran after her and chased her out of Beecher's Hope, towards the Great Plains and eventually caught up to her and killed her, again with the shotgun. Restarted me again to the previous saved level.
Another one I did was with the Funny Man side mission. That guy really annoyed the heck out of me, always getting caught. Then finally when he decides that lifestyle isn't for him and he's got to get out of there, and I finally got that "Funny Man Completed" notice at the bottom, thats when I knew that a Shotgun Blast to the head while he was running away was in order.
And with the Poppycock side mission where you deliver opium to that other guy. I chose to give the guy back the $1,000, but after I got the mission complete, I hogtied, took him to the middle of nowhere, shot him in the head execution style, and just looted back the $1,000.
Honestly, I know these make me sound terrible, but aside from these, my honor was actually as perfect as can be.

I shot and killed a dog in armadillo

This message has been deleted.

Oh alright I gotcha. Old School.
Thanks

Curious, how do you do the spoiler blocking thing?
When you post a messgae/reply.
See above where it says "Body text"? Next to it is a button labled "markup enabled". Click it.
The greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world he is God.

Oh and I used a nun to get the Dastardly achievement. I felt kind of bad until I saw the train hit her, then it was just funny.
I tried to use a nun to get that achievement too. Must have encountered the only nitro nun in the game though, because I could not catch the bint, like lightning, she was!

Thanks, I'll try that. It might've been too powerful a gun I had.

@Fwank, try using pistols or revolvers that's what I used when it happened as I'm trying to get the Hail of Bullets trophy. Otherwise though you're right, most NPCs will try to crawl away an die shortly after being shot in both legs, it's only been gang members that have put up a fight after being shot multiple times. I could of sworn it took as least 4-5 shots to kill one gang member in Nosalida last night. I shot him in the arm an leg whilst in dead-eye and running for cover, when I got behind the wall I could see him crawling away an the Mexican army were still shooting him, looked bloody brutal!
I like wotsits