Tim Olyphant would make a great John Marston

When I was playing this game, in my mind I was like..geez Heath Ledger would make a great professor McDougall. He played similar character in The Brother's Grimm

Get rid of Clooney, Hedlund, Brolin, Hamm, Danny beep Trejo, Logue, Kurt Russell(can suck a D), and Theron too. The rest, I like. Especially the Coen Bros and Daniel Day-Lewis. Jaoquin Phoenix would do well as Marston, I think. I love that you put John Hawkes in there!
I really wish Hollywood would make a movie using some of these characters and storyline. A lot of the game has some corny characters that wouldn't work well on screen, such as Nigel West Dickens.
Anyway, I loved this game. Hope they come out with another one soon!

Josh Brolin as John Marston
Donal Logue as Bill Williamson
Daniel Day-Lewis as Dutch Van Der Linde
Javier Bardem as Javier Escuella
Garret Dillahunt as Norman Deek
Charlize Theron as Bonnie Macfarlane
Tommy Lee Jones as Drew Macfarlane
Sarah Paulson as Abigail Marston
Gerald McRaney as Uncle
Jim Beaver as Marshal Leigh Johnson
John Hawkes as Jonah
Jonah Hill as Eli
Steve Buscemi as Seth Briars
Colin Farrell as Irish
Dustin Hoffman as Nigel West Dickens
Kurt Russell as Landon Ricketts
Michael Pena as Abraham Reyes
America Ferrera as Luisa Fortuna
Oscar Isaac as Captain Vincent De Santa
Benicio Del Toro as Colonel Augustus Allende
Danny Trejo as Captain Espinoza
George Clooney as Edgar Ross
Lee Pace as Harold McDougal
Adam Beach as Nastas
Jon Hamm as Archer Fordham
(idk) - Jack Marston (Younger)
Garret Hedlund - Jack Marston (Older)
Directed by The Coen Bros.
Written by The Coen Bros.
Oh and it's a miniseries on HBO, not a movie.
Praise the Lord and pass the ammunition.

I've always imagined Norman Reedus playing John, but everyone's ideas sound great!

I was just watching the tv show Banshee and it occurred to me that Antony Starr would be a great John Marston.

Actually, I think the best person to play West-Dickens would be the man who actually voiced him. I can't recall his name, but he played Mr. Sweeney in Ned's Declassified School Survuval Guide.

came here to see if anyone else thought he looked like karl urban hes my choice dont know if he has the acting chops or the accent to do it

Karl Urban looks like john marston?!

Wasn't there already a Daniel Day-Lewis type of character in the game by the oil fields?

I like Daniel Day-Lewis or Christian Bale for John Marston though they both should put on some weight first. I always pictured Scarlett johansson as Bonnie and Kate Mara as Abigail. Also I think Robin Williams would play the perfect Nigel West Dickens or maybe even Danny Devito