Pirates who turned into zombies.

zombie pirates
or
pirate zombies?
"Insults are the arguments employed by those who are in the wrong." J.J. Rousseau

It could happen. If Murphy bases a story on the pirates that were active in America way back when and put a spin on it that has elements of "The Fog" movie, then just make them hungry for human flesh for some reason, there you go. Lol

How could I forget to list that one!?! Schpadoinkle was my ringtone for years. XD
Now I want to see what Ryan Murphy/AHS could do with Alferd Packer or the Donner Party!

How about Cannibal! The Musical? Lol

Oh, don't be a spoil-sport! Some of us like to have fun with the shows we watch! Let people enjoy both AHS and South Park, rather than being a big old negative Nellie and suggesting they die.
Besides which, there are worse musicals out there, ones that don't speak to niche interests like horror. Any horror musical apart from Sweeney Todd, Rocky Horror, and Repo would be welcomed by me!
Let a little love in your heart, why doncha?

Oh please die!

I would seriously pay big, BIG money if they collaborated and made an AHS Broadway musical. So hope their people read these boards! XD

AHS: Roanoke isn't written by Trey Parker and Matt Stone?
They could have fooled me.

Now, would they be pirates who died and became ghosts, or people who died, became ghosts, and then decided to become pirates?
Wait Where's KORN and the Antonio Banderas blow-up doll? What do you mean this isn't the South Park board? AHS: Roanoke isn't written by Trey Parker and Matt Stone?