It's a scene that calls back to something from the first movie, and is also very in line with all the weird technobabble solutions in the original series.

Yeah, it seemed very out of place for me when viewing the movie. Still a decent flick though.

no she was listening to some other track earlier on, wasn't Sabotage

Another joke, with reference to the "classical music" quote, is if we know look back just two films to ST09:-
When Kirk is zooming along in the "borrowed" Corvette, blasting out The Beastie Boys, I originally assumed we were to view that as showing young James Tiberius Kirk as being quite the rebel. Now, however, we are told that he was actually driving the three hundred year old vehicle listening to what was considered "classical" music.
We should therefore perhaps be viewing that scene as more akin to watching young Kirk teetering atop a penny-farthing, enjoying the sounds of Beethoven's mass in c major, or suchlike, emanating from a nearby gramaphone!
Not so rebellious now
The
truth
about Marti Pellow

the beastie boys can't even exist in the star trek universe. They literally reference star trek in their lyrics. So the beastie boys are from a world where star trek was a tv show from the 60's that they watched as reruns in the 70's. Are they now saying that star trek is now our future? even during TNG they still persisted in the canon of the eugenics wars of the 1990's, and ill communication came out in 1994, right in the middle of the eugenics wars. khan was in the second kelvin timeline movie, so obviously they haven't abandoned that as canonical. this just shows poor knowledge of trek lore, poor knowledge of an audience, and not taking your material seriously enough. maybe the next one can have william shatner come back as tj hooker and he can ride on the hood of the enterprise with heather locklear. and it can be a big wink at the audience like, get it?

What part of "It was clearly a joke" didn't you get?
As that great philosopher Bugs Bunny said, "Something tells me I shoulda stood in bed."

If in the future the works stephanie Meyer and her pen name that wrote fifty shades of grey created are Giants of literature then civikization will have come to an end and anyone capable of inventing warp drive will no longer Exist and interstellar travel will not eirher

The reference to it as classical reminded me of the "Ah, the `Giants'" scene in Star Trek IV. It was clearly a joke about what things from the past filtered through to their present time after the turmoils in between those time eras, such as the world war the predated First Contact.
As that great philosopher Bugs Bunny said, "Something tells me I shoulda stood in bed."

Wasn't he requested classical music for him to play instead of declaring that it was?
~Jesus wept.~

Heck I liked it, especially when Yorktown did their broadcast thing.

1. BVS 2. TWS 3. Avengers

To quote live free or die hsrd
Referring to a old rock radio station mcclane was playing
"Its not classic just old"

Classic rock and classical are not the same thing.
Classical refers to music made with the instruments before electricity. Violin. Cello. Piano. Flutes. Etcc. Classical.

What was called Rock n' Roll in the '80s and before is already called Classic Rock. We don't know what they'll call any ere/genre of music until we get there.
Someone ever tries to kill you you try to kill em right back.

The specific definition of classical music is from the 1750-1830s emerging from the Renaissance era. There are college courses specifically for this genre of music and period in world history.
I doubt the teachings at starfleet academy would change standard education of periods in history just because another genre of music is old. (Beastie boys being rap)
Bar fights, motorcycles..rap music this is a far departure from star trek TV series at least.
Maybe I've become accustomed to Picard/Janeway portrayals of strict protocols aboard a starship. These films are decent in their own unique way. Just not what I've come to expect after watching DS9, TNG & voyager.

No it's not. Your just using a literal definition. Classical is a genre that transcends it's literal meaning. Beastie boys 200 years from now will be defined by an era. Like music from the 20s or 50s or 80s has. Or the 70s. All bygone eras, but they're not defined as classical.

A paragraph of sheer unadulterated pretentious snot. Classic music is dated music from a bygone era.

Cause classical music will always be classical music. Beastie boys will never be called classical music no matter how far in the future one goes. In 200 years why would the works of Bach and Mozart have become lost and teplaced with something that doesn't even resemble classical on any form? It's been 200 years or more now and classical is still classical. We don't call music from the 20s classical now and never will. Why would we in a mere 200 years more?

Why's the classical music bit dumb?
https://zitzelfilm.wordpress.com

Agreean d calling it classical music? dumb dumb dumb.
if you played the scene on its own, it would have made a nice music video maybe.
but it was beyond dumb and stupid to interject it into a star trek film and use it to save all mankind. they had been setting it up the whole flick though when they showed the alien girl listening to it in the ship she found or whatever

Itworks for me. But I can get others finding it too much.
https://zitzelfilm.wordpress.com

It's funny you said that - either yes they were, or (and no one on my thread actually discussed this, but it was my original thought) it was a deliberate, subtle, joke at the expense at those complaining the reboots weren't "cerebral" / Star Trek-ish enough
This would make for an interesting interview question! Indeed, that whole scene would

Yeah, I know we discussed on the other thread - and yes, as I said there as well, I did find it enjoyable, as a spectacle, whilst watching. I was only really replying in order to point out the misunderstanding in brch2's post in terms of a "least contrived method"
I am starting to wonder if the writers were confused too!
It's funny you said that - either yes they were, or (and no one on my thread actually discussed this, but it was my original thought) it was a deliberate, subtle, joke at the expense at those complaining the reboots weren't "cerebral" / Star Trek-ish enough.
I think you can appreciate this better once you understand swarm dynamics.
Ha - It's not that I don't understand your take on it, its just that I preferred to think of another method being used for collision avoidance (I don't know - proximity sensors of some other kind - maybe cameras / "artificial eye") rather than thousands of overlapping communication transmissions, which would just make the Franklin's one additional transmission completely redundant.
The
truth
about Marti Pellow

I don't see how these are problems? We discussed this already in another thread. There was no need to play the music on the bridge but it was included for dramatic effect.
Unfortunately, as you mentioned in your thread, this part has confused so many people that I am starting to wonder if the writers were confused too!
I actually like the scene because of Spock's improvised hijack of their collision avoidance. I think you can appreciate this better once you understand swarm dynamics.
Of course it was ridiculously OTT but this was par the norm for this film!

Would you be able to concentrate with that blasting through your speakers while having to fly in a very tight formation in an attack? And broadcasting on the frequency they were using for their computers to maintain all of that is just scrambling the signal, something that has been done for years to interrupt military radios and their abilities to coordinate attacks. So what's the problem?
You've just given the problem in your two preceding sentences here

1. It is pretty much impossible that there could have been any music "blasting" anywhere other than the bridge of the Franklin.
2. As you pointed out, they broadcast on the same frequency to "scramble" communication within the swarm - that would be by wave interference. So even in the hugely unlikely event that they were receiving verbal directional instructions on an analogue transmission (!),
   both
   transmissions would be subject to interference
   In other words, they came up with nonsense simply because it played out as a "cool" scene, with Sabotage blaring out as ships exploded everywhere!
   The
   truth
   about Marti Pellow