It wasn't disturbing in any way; it is on the same level as every other episode.

The ends do not justify the means, no matter how guilty the perp may be - that is one of the Gold Standards by which the criminal justice system operates and is implemented; and an edict that no one, Police Precinct Captain or other, is above.
I believe that by the the end of the series, this will prove to be one of the major laudable attributes recognized in Jim Gordon when he is eventually given the position of Gotham City Police Commissioner; and one of the major reasons that the adult Bruce Wayne puts his trust in Gordon, when he (as his secret unknown alter ego "Batman") becomes a uniquely deputized law enforcement agent under the auspices of Gordon.
God did not create man in his own image; man created god in his own image.

They still did the deed despite they were surrendering. Simon knew he would walk, so why risk it a second time? A criminal is a criminal. No innocents were killed as I stated. And even that douche that got his face cut up, he too was a criminal.

No, in both cases he killed people who were surrendering and he could have arrested. In both cases there was also evidence to put them away. There was plenty of evidence to put cleaner away for life of give him the death penalty. There came for Simon because they had DNA evidence on him. So both were unnecessary and the law had not failed.
Now, if Simon still got out again, that would be another situation. But at the time it was unjustified murder.

Need a new signature?
Why not Zoidberg? (/)(;,;)(/)

personally, Barnes did nothing wrong. He didn't kill innocent people, he killed criminals that thought and think they're above the law. Sometimes the law fails.

"The Thing", AKA Ben Grimm, lives. Yeah, I know this is a DC universe show, but the episode gave me a Marvel Flashback.

It was creepy in a good way. Barnes really owned this episode. He's been good all season, but Chiklis really brought it brilliantly in this one. He didn't quite have the heir of self-righteousness that he had in Season 2. I'm glad he took down his vitriol a notch. I loved his interactions with Jim. They seemed way more genuine than the ones he had in Season 2.

This was the best one so far this season. I was glued lol

There were some creepy moments in the episode.
If it's all the same to you, I'll have that drink now.-Loki (Marvel's Avengers)

Best episode of the season.

This might have been their Halloween episode, just a week late. Still very good though.

Really coming out of his shell, yeah.
They were pretty rough, but they had something.
What was it?
I think it was the trousers.

I actually liked Barnes turning violent and start killing people brutally.
Asteroid Mike Reviews (my YouTube channel)
https://www.youtube.com/c/AsteroidMike

When I saw that through-the-wall bit, I reflexively channelled "The Boy Wonder", saying out loud to myself Robin's 1960s-esque likely response if he were to see that - updated for today's more hardened sensibilities:
"HOLY SH!T, BATMAN!!".
He would totally say that today, re that scene
God did not create man in his own image; man created god in his own image.

He was wearing a plot-armor

With Barnes slamming Dr. Simon right through a wall to the street, how was it possible for him to live, much less long enough to gasp out that Barnes was the one who did it to him? Shouldn't his body have been crushed by the impact with the wall? But this is
Gotham
, and I've learned I have to suspend belief.
They were pretty rough, but they had something.
What was it?
I think it was the trousers.

I didn't see anything wrong with it. It was intense, deep and dark, yet still entertaining. I have been glued to every episode since the show's debut but this season is so amazing. But we owe it to the actors, writers and producers who are making it this way.
Accept what is, let go of what was, have faith in what will be