That's an old list, I've since reread the entire series and made some adjustments. I can see Lily Cole or perhaps (and probably not) Natalie Portman as Mina.
And as far as Depp goes, screw him. We don't need him, especially for a role as small as Mack.
I now challenge you to recast every single character I mentioned. We'll compare notes when you're done.
But seriously, how can you hate Ron Pearlman as Hyde? He was born to play Hyde.
OK, Rabbit. We like it. We like your plan.

Wow congratulations on showing your complete lack of , well anything to be honest.
Keira Knightley ? you lost any sense or shred of being taken seriously at the first member of your cast list, there is more acting potential in a parrot than that girl will ever exhibit.
Johnny Depp ? whats wrong with Depp ? A) hes very good at playing off the wall/wacky characters B) he brings MONEY and lots of it and the only way any film is going to get made/ have sequel prequel chances are if they make money and your cast list just. wont.
Try again
Its Eyre as in head.

No problem at all, my good man. I've come to accept that people on IMDb are going to exaggerate their oppinions, for better or for worse. I've heard way, way worse things on here. I'm glad you like the rest of my casting. Its an old list, however. I've made a revised version of it, if I can dig that up, I'll post it on here.
No need to feel guilty at all
You shut your mouth when you're talking to me!

OMG, I am sooo sorry for being so nasty to you. I feel so guilty! But thanks a gazillion for the apology. It really warmed my heart.
BTW, your casting was absolutely fabulous.
Please read my blog!
http://rolando8.livejournal.com/

Here's why, and believe me, I knew I would take heat for this, but the Threepenny Opera section kept reminding me of Sweeney Todd. I was envisioning them with Carter and Depp's singing voices. Sorry, Rolando. Other than that, how was the casting?
All the Young Dudes Carry the News

WHAT ON EARTH IS WRONG WITH YOU!?!?!?! The Universe told me that, if Johnny Depp was mentioned in your post, that the Universe would end!!! I kept thinking, 'No, you wouldn't put Johnny Depp in this list', but YOU DID!!! YOU MONSTER!!!!!

My mistake. I havn't read it since last summer. Not bad casting though, eh?
Alice Army

This message has been deleted.

This series had so much potential to be great and they just effed it up. I think it needs a serious reboot in the vien of Batman Begins or The Increadable Hulk. If it were to be rebooted into a franchise, here's my cast list:
Directed by Terry Gilliam
Writtin By Alan Moore himself (which will never happen) or perhaps me. I think I could write a wonderful League adaptation
Here's a complete cast list of who and what I'd like to see in a rebooted big budget film series based on the comics:
Kira Knightly as Mina Murry
Harrison Ford as Allen Quatermain
Ben Kingsly as Capt. Nemo
Simon Pegg as Hawley Gryphon
Adrien Brodey as Dr. Jekyll
Ron Pearlman as Mr. Hyde
Pierce Brosnand as Campion Bond
William Hurt as C. August Dupin
Sao Yun Fat as Fu Manchu
Peter O'Toole as James Moriarty
Keith Carridine as Dr. Moreau
Kate Blachet as Orlando
Alan Moore Himself as Prospero
Bob Hoskins as Caliban
Clair Danes as Ariel
John Hurt as Don Quixote
Louis Guzman as Sanchopanza
Daniel Day Lewis as Gulliver
Daniel Radcliff as Natty Bumpo
Scarlett Johanson as Fanny Hill
Jude Law as Young Allen Quatermain
Christian Bale as "Jimmy" Bond
Malin Ackerman as Emma Knight
Alfred Molina as Hugo Drummond
Michael Kane as Big Brother/Robert Kim Cherry/Harry Lime/Mother/M
Danny DeVito as Dr. Calligari
Willem Defoe as Rotwag
Leonardo De Caprio as Arsne Lupin
Michael Clark Duncan as Fantomas
Brad Dourif as Monsouir Zenith
Christopher Lee as Robur the Conquorer
Phillip Seymore Hoffman as Doctor Mabuse
Hillary Swank as Miss Jane Warrleson
Billy Zane as Peter Brady
Sped-Up Voice of James Earl Jones & CGI as The Fearless Bold Black Balloonist
Frida Pinto as Janni
Johnny Depp as Jack MacHeath
Helena Boham Carter as The Nameless Woman from the Threepenny Opera section
Garry Oldman as Oliver Haddo
Robert Downey, Jr. as Thomas Carknaki
The Blazing World segment would have to be done in 3-D. What do you think?
Alice Army

Oh i love questions like these:
my dream cast for the black dossier would be:
Characters:
Mina Harker - Natalie Portman (i reckon she has Mina's spikiness)
Alan Quartermain - Tom Hardy (is just great all round)
Jimmy Bond - Henry Cavill (should have been Bond in the first place!)
Emma Night - Emily Blunt (definitely slinky enough)
Orlando - Cillian Murphy (was very convincing in Breakfast On Pluto)
Hugo Drummond - Ray Stevenson (is big enough - would have to add facial scars)
Fanny Hill - Emile De Ravin (would love to hear her attempt at a British accent)
Prospero - Ian McKellan or maybe Christopher Lee (obvious choices I know)
Change Anything?
I've no idea how one would even adapt this into a film, it refers to the pairs previous escapades with the league and also Orlando's. Also ties together an insane amount of literature.
Genre:
Fantasy, Sci-fi, Steam-punk, Thriller, with kickass 3-D for the Blazing World segment
dairy for me, none for the non-believers!

i'd like to see christian bale as "jimmy." i know he never played Bond befor, but he's such a masogenistic @$$ in real life the role was tailor made for him
Alice Army
My Mother says To Get Things Done You Better Not Mess with Major Tom

Maybe Daniel Craig could take on the role of "Jimmy"
Only the dead have seen the end of war.
Plato

Hell would have to freeze over before this would ever happen. Either that or it'd have to play out with Moore and Gilliam working on something that isn't based on anything Moore wrote.

doubt it would ever happen
but my choice would be Terry Gilliam to direct whilst working closely with Moore

This message has been deleted.

I'd like to see it as maybe a direct-to-video film with all the bonus stuff that was included in the dossier as DVD/Blu-Ray bonus features