This message has been deleted.

I Do wish they would do a movie together.
When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth

Charlize.
I thought Kate originally but then I saw photos of her outside underworld and realize I like her in her vampire makeup more than in real life.

Very, very slightly prefer Kate Beckinsale, though that may be because I just recently rewatched Underworld: Awakening and was given an hour and a half reminder of how much I love this woman's so-pretty-it-hurts face and amazing body (the scene with her crawling in the ventilation shaft and giving us that shot of her stunning ass should have been shot in slow motion for a full two minutes!). That said, I reserve the right to change my opinion or call it a tie after watching Snow White and Prometheus. Bottom line, though, both women set my loins aflame.

Although by objective standards Charlize Theron's beauty might be considered a bit more "classic" than Kate's and sometimes photographs doesn't always do Kate justice (in my opinion), I definitely prefer Kate Beckinsale.

Funny how both these women are Leo's, like me. We are the kings and queens.

Trying to choose almost made my head explode Scanners style.

Darn ! I must be British !
I'm not a woman much less Deanna Durbin, but the old-time glam-shot appeals to me.

This message has been deleted.

WOW she is 38! I just wikied her, she is gorgeous. Also I looked for pictures of her and I love her smile and her teeth, and yet she is British! I guess the stereotype of bad teeth is pretty outdated.

It's a tie. They're both so gorgeous and beep I can't choose.
How about anything where they play lesbian lovers who are also covert assassins?

Charlize. I find Kate Beckinsale very boring. I can see why should would be popular in the UK, but she strikes me as not being anything special beyond being better than average looking. But I'm just one guy, and she is quite popular.

This message has been deleted.

What kind of film would you like to see them together?
Do you know that picture with the 7 dolphins that kinda look like lovers? Never saw a dolphin in that one.
I think humanity should be wiped out and then we can give evolution a second chance.

In the looks department I'd go for Kate, though Charlize is certainly no hag either (except maybe in Monster, haha). As for the characters duking it out, Selene would wipe the floor with Aeon, but then it's not really a fair contest anyway. In the talent department I'd give the edge to Charlize, though.

Depends. In action movie, Kate is better, but in terms of drama, Charlize is unbeatable.
Straight Edge is the only way to be free.
Rachel Weisz FOR Catwoman!

Love them both!!!!! but Theron for the edge.

This message has been deleted.

Kate Beckinsale for sure.
And as far as what kind of movie I'd like to see them in together, I'll have to go with a Lesbian Porno.

They are both gorgeous, but personally I prefer Kate. When you referred to them as goddesses, it made me picture them in an Olympian drama. Maybe with Kate as Athena and Charlize as Hera? it would be epic to say the least.
Toto, I don't think we're in Georgia anymore

I'm not going to argue with you about her eyes being little.

My baby Kate easily! That sexy body, those gorgeous smooth sexy legs, that tight firm booty! those cute little eyes. That mischievous cute smile. To me Kate is flawless, and i'd love to have any type of freaky sex with her.
" I'm Hardcore To The Bone, I'm Thuggish Ruggish "

Really? Kate looks like she would do Charlize's laundry. Fluff and fold, the works. Maybe if she has time, she'll can pour the wine for Charlize's dinner party and she must not forget cleaning the stains on her apron.

Charlize. Though Kate comes in at number 2 on my most beautiful actress list.
I'm judging based on what they look like in films and interviews since that's all I've ever seen either in.