To answer this question, I've gone on YouTube and Google to check back their interview video clips and still images to refresh my memory. A comparison of their beauty during their peaks would yield an even result, i.e. they were both gorgeously beautiful in their own ways and there are no ways or reasons to pick one over another. However, as of now 2015, I would favor Brooke since I can see she has been aging better than Olivia. Brooke is with a more healthy look and a happy aura, while Olivia is with a haggard look and struggling appearance. Olivia's smoking habit (since the age of 14) has done obvious damage to her skin (and health). Brooke lives a clean and healthy life (a vegan, non-smoker/drinker)and seems to be with a better career/family life.

I've given this some thought, and I'm ready to answer. Both women are gorgeous, but I'm going to have to go with Olivia Hussey. I'm a straight and happily married woman, but I do occasionally notice women, and I'm particularly drawn to willowy women with delicate features. Olivia Hussey fits that description better than Brooke Shields (even though I idolized Brooke Shields growing up).

I saw that, that was simple and a copy of Lynda Carter. Olivia Hussey is ugly Olivia Hussey is ugly Olivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is uglyOlivia Hussey is ugly

I met Olivia Hussey when she was 18-19 and she was drop dead stunning! Small, perfect skin, beautiful natural coloring, little if no makeup. She and I had a conversation about the costumes she wore in Romeo and Juliet and her new puppy. Delightful, unaffected, and extremely friendly and open. Never met Brooke, but I'll give my 2 cents to Olivia Hussey any day for beautiful woman.
What would Joan say?

I called Olivia a "he" instead of she on that Raquel Welch lineNo I won't apologize

Finally someone with intelligence, Brooke shields was beautiful and decent better than the stupid Olviia Hussey.

Wow! Look at all you Hussey stans sorry but comparing Olivia Hussey and Brooke Shields is like comparing wicked witch of Oz to Nicole Kidman.
Olivia in Black Christmas, her expression is blank like a simple cartoon, she is no Raquel Welch, he is not sensual or supermodel sexy.
Brooke Shields is like Yasmin Bleeth and Kristy Ally - they are Gorgeous, wild looking, auburn hair and cat-like blue eyes, she is sexier and better looking than Olivia.
If Olivia is so muchcoughbetter then how come her career didn't take off, because Brooke Shields is more sexy, charismatic and a smarter actress, same with Elizabeth Taylor who is more stunning than Hussey too.
The only thing is interesting is the name Hussey, and it is only a stage name lol

Brooke shields was beautiful and decent better than the stupid Olviia Hussey. Her face was smaller and oval face. Olivia Hussey is ugly.
Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly.

Olivia Hussey, who in my opinion is in a class all her own.

Lol! Poor of you you don't know nothing about natural beauty of Brooke Shields!
Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly .Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly.. Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly. . Olivia Hussey is ugly. Olivia Hussey is ugly.

Is this a legitimate comparison?
Olivia; no contest.

Lol! Poor of you you don't know nothing about natural beauty of Brooke Shields!
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Ugly Olivia Hussey
Brooke wins.

Easily Hussy.

Look her in ponytail, so ugly, She's bald

Olivia Hussey

But Brooke more so. Still very beautiful but her prime was 12 up to 15. From then on, her features became more masculine. Same thing happened with Katerina Witt. Both were prettier in their early teens than in their 20's. Some women peak early.

They peaked very early, at an age when most girls are still awkward. I went to school with a girl who was very beautiful at 12, but by the time we graduated from high school guys thought she was ugly. It was very strange.
The best things are last

What drugs are all of you taking to use the past tense "was"?! Both these women are both still beautiful! You must have some screws loose if you think Olivia or Brooke were only beautiful when they were young. It also makes me think you people must be very shallow and vapid to think a person, let alone a woman, can only be beautiful in their youth.
If it's been fifteen years or more, it's no longer a spoiler.

Both of them peaked very early and unfortunately "fell off" shortly afterward. Olivia had the advantage of superior coloring (that lustrous raven mane and those incandescent silver-green eyes
) and a more dreamy/romantic quality to her look overall, but I'd argue that the interplay between Brooke's actual features was more impressive. There was a brief moment in time where her face was all but perfect from an aesthetic viewpoint.
http://i45.tinypic.com/2cpay37.jpg

Lol! Poor of you you don't know nothing about natural beauty of Brooke Shields!
Ugly Olivia Hussey

Disgusting and stupid. Brooke Shields was prettier in 1979, Olivia is ugly without eyebrows and larger face

You're blind Olivia is ugly compared to Brooke look at her forehead

SEE:
https://selfserviceuk.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/brooke-shields-80s-vogue-cover1.jpg
.

I've never understood what people saw in brook shields looks so I'll have to go for Olivia Hussey.