That's so true- -I just saw him on a new episode of THE MENTALIST (saw his name in the credits, and wondered what he looks like now since NIGHTBREED's the only flick I recall seeing him in.) At first I really did think that Boreanaz was on the show, but then I noticed that while the actor looked like him, it wasn't really him. It wasn't until he appeared near the end that I realized, "Oh, dang, that's Craig Sheffer!" I was surprised to come on IMDB and find that he's pushing near 50, because he looks pretty damn good for his agequite a surprise! Another actor I think he actually looks more like is Stephen Dorffnow both of them could definitely pass as brothers in a film,I think!

agreed!
especially when you compare these two photos
Craig (when he was a bit younger)
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm2915080704/nm0001729
David
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm3767704064/nm0004770

I don't know who David Boreanaz is, but to me, he looks like
Josh Brolin
.
I always tell the trutheven when I lie

• Scarface

Have to agree they look very much alike

I totally agree. David Boreanaz looks better though when I saw the Pilot of OTH I thought it's David and I was sad, because I thought he lost some of his good look

I agree if they ever bring Jared Booth (David Boreanaz's character's brother) in on Bones they should cast Craig Sheffer for sure.
Spike: What? I'm listening with beer.

I've always thought the same thing!

What I would like to know is why they haven't been cast as brothers in a movie. When they are lucky enough to have such similarities in actors, TAKE ADVANTAGE OF IT!!!
Save the Earth-It's the only planet with chocolate!

I just watched Baby Cakes from the 80's and was totally convinced by the end that the main male character was David Boreanz only to discover Craig Sheffer. So strange!

I'm just watching him in Dracula II and that occured to me.
Goodnight, good luck, and may your God go with you.

I was watching Turulance 3 I noticed it, then I noticed I was watching Turbulance 3. Bad times.

When I saw him in OTH, I first thought he was David Boreanaz, but when I realized it wasn't him, I wondered where I knew him from. Then I realized that from my childhood, I saw him on t.v. in Nightbreed and I admit, I was "ga-ga" over him. Yep, I think Craig could hold his own in a looks contest with David (not to mention acting ability). It's easy to believe and love him as Keith! His acting has always been believable, and as he has gotten older, he has just become better. He's an actor that I'd like to see get more work not just as the Uncle or the side kick.

Yeah You Kinda Have A Point Th1908ere lol

Well technically, since Craig was born first, David Boreanaz looks like him. But you're right - the first time I saw One Tree Hill I thought David Boreanaz was doing a cameo. They look so alike.

lol yeah they look really alike!

Yeah lol

When he has his hair cut short, he REALLY does!