Roosevelt, The Best President
-
saint_pat — 20 years ago(November 07, 2005 03:22 PM)
"the NRA (national recovery administration) set prices for goods at above market value. If that's not socialism then I don't know what is."
The national recovery administration gave workers the right to join labor unions and helped ensure wages rose alongside industrial growth. This was extremely beneficial for both workers and businesses alike.
"FDR's bank branch restrictions caused 90% of bank failures."
I'd like to know what links you're using to support these claims. All the studies I've read show that bank failures virtually ended under FDR and that bank depositing soared.
"Federal taxes tripled."
Only on the major corporations and wealthiest segments of society.
"People had less money to spend."
Nonsense. All studies show that consumer spending went up under FDR. Tha5b4nks to wage and price regulation and labor bartering, lower income Americans actually had MORE money to spend.
"I like capitalism because the private industry saved America from the Great Depression."
Completely untrue. The private industry was failing until FDR took over. Barring a brief relapse in '37, the economy steadily grew under FDR. Even Republicans don't deny that. And it was government reinforcement of industry during WW2 that saved America from the Great Depression.
The New Deal was not a total success, but it was far from a failure. Wages did increase and unemployment did drop (from 25% in 1933 to 17% in 1939). -
-
coxm-1 — 20 years ago(March 22, 2006 08:37 AM)
FDR saved this country - TWICE! He pulled us out of the depression; and he was smarted enough to win WWII. What tth0r said is very true. It's only the modern day conservative radio twits, and their blind disciples, that have been saying this socialism crap about FDR. If he was so bad for America, why did Americans elect him to four terms as President?
-
keeleboy — 18 years ago(June 02, 2007 03:14 PM)
Fair enough point, but at least FDR didn't wait too long to join the war against the Nazis. Without the great help the US offered in 1942 then maybe Europe would be a different place. Roosevelt (after extracting benefits for the US) at least helped the war effor well before Wilson decided that Kaiser Wilhelm was a menace
-
YodaFan465 — 20 years ago(May 08, 2005 04:06 PM)
FDR a great person? I think not. He didn't get us out of the Depression as he promised, and he dragged us into a World War. Even before Pearl Harbor, he was selling weapons to the belligerents and "conquering" places like Iceland and Newfoundland.
He even sent troops into the Philippines to "watch" the Japanese. If we had no intention of getting into the war (he always pledged to stay neutral, despite engaging in the Atlantic Charter), why was my great-uncle forced into combat with the Japanese before Pearl Harbor? Because of FDR, my great-uncle Frank Yonan (look him up if you don't believe me) had to 2000spend 3+ years in a Japanese prison camp. Ever hear of the Bataan Death March? My great-uncle was there, and it was FDR's fault. We shouldn't have been in Manila before Pearl Harbor.
Another note, FDR did nothing to free the Bataan prisoners. I believe that they received a total of 2 Red Cross care packages, but I KNOW that Uncle Frank had to free himself from the camps. MacArthur, who abandoned his troops, didn't come to liberate our boys from Bataan.
FDR a great person? I think not.
ALIAS fans visit
http://www.addictedtoalias.net
Tell 'em YodaFan465 sent you. -
Balberith — 20 years ago(August 25, 2005 09:56 PM)
Well by the time the Yalta conference took place in February of 1945 Roosevelt was pretty much senile. His worst moment by far was putting Japanese Americans in internment camps without the apporval of congress.
"A real man would rather bow down to a strong woman than dominate a weak one" -
Idocamstuf — 20 years ago(September 11, 2005 07:53 PM)
FDR was at the very least the best president of the twentieth century. He brought America hope during one of the darkest periods in our history. Not to mention his programs that created millions of jobs for hard working Americans, and his creation of social security in 1935. We need more presidents like FDR, somebody with the true integrity to fight for the average hard working American and not back down. FDR will always be my picture of how a true American president should be.
-
manny535 — 20 years ago(September 17, 2005 07:19 PM)
FDR was the best presidents of the 20th Century. He championed the common man and restored hope the nation. For the time being, the entire country decided that he was the savior. But like all men, his public charm masked his private struggles.
-
tim0122 — 20 years ago(January 16, 2006 06:22 PM)
Ok I don't know if anyone else has said this but I don't think a lot of people credit FDR for getting the USA out of the great depression but they do credit him for Greatly making the USA better and
imrpoving people's lives during the great depression.
"There hasn't been an original idea since the beginning of time"- Mark Twain -
weezer-20 — 19 years ago(April 15, 2006 08:24 AM)
I don't understand how anybody could see FDR as a bad president. Most people just don't realize the enormity of the situation Roosevelt entered. He dealt with both of the biggest emergencies in the 20th century (the Great Depression and World War II) and he managed to preserve our democracy (it is nonsense to consider FDR's America anywhere near Soviet-style socialism). His critics fail to realize that shortly after the stock market crash, the country was on a verge of a communist (or perhaps even a fascist) revolution. The crisis was so bad that fringe extreme left figures like Huey Long and Charles Coughlin were expressing what were considered to be mainstream views in the climate of economic ruin and capitalist failure. In this climate, FDR was anything but a socialist; he was a moderate, even right wing according to Long.
This, in addition to FDR being elected four times in a row, and several opponents of his openly breaking down and expressing their admiration for the man on the news of his death. Historians (liberal and conservative alike) generally agree without question that FDR, despite his flaws, was the best president of the 20th century.
In my view, he was our best president. He saw the character of America and put the fate of our democracy, and the fate of our world, in our hands. Before Roosevelt America was a wealthy but weak banker for the European nations. After Roosevelt it was transformed into the most powerful nation in the world. He knew something about us that no other politician did, and he trusted us by giving us the world. We are living in the world he envisioned - not Hitler's world, or Stalin's world or even Churchill's world. We should all be very grateful. -
tjvs — 19 years ago(May 02, 2006 12:15 AM)
roosevelt was a warmonger who was led by 73 jewish "advisers" who pushed america into a war it had no buisness in don't beleive look it up i'll name just a few bernard baruch jokingly called the "real" president sam rosenman his speechwriter, felix frankfurter,ben cohen henry morgenthau,stephen wise and many more kinda like the jews behind bush like wolfowitz, pearle, kristoll and company
-
coxm-1 — 18 years ago(July 12, 2007 06:13 AM)
"roosevelt was a warmonger who was led by 73 jewish "advisers" who pushed america into a war it had no buisness in don't beleive look it up i'll name just a few bernard baruch jokingly called the "real" president sam rosenman his speechwriter, felix frankfurter,ben cohen henry morgenthau,stephen wise and many more kinda like the jews behind bush like wolfowitz, pearle, kristoll and company"
And here I thought Hitler was dead. Apparently he's alive and posting on the net as tjvs.