Needs a serious re-make…
-
-
friendoffilm — 10 years ago(November 24, 2015 06:43 AM)
Hi, bradford-1. Good to see you posting here again.
Your points are well taken. Thanks. As I've pointed out on other threads on this post, but it bears repeating, a re-make of the movie
West Side Story
, especially without the music and songs, etc., would be an utter and total fiasco, because it would absolutely cut the heart and soul right out of it. -
friendoffilm — 10 years ago(November 24, 2015 06:44 AM)
Hi, bradford-1. Good to see you posting here again.
Your points are well taken. Thanks. As I've pointed out on other threads on this post, but it bears repeating, a re-make of the movie
West Side Story
, especially without the music and songs, etc., would be an utter and total fiasco, because it would absolutely cut the heart and soul right out of it. -
boxerrebellion — 9 years ago(August 29, 2016 06:46 PM)
Oh, Good Grief! How could
anyone
say the music blows?
I came late to Sweeney Todd (the idea of the plot sort of creeped me out), but as soon as I heard the music and lyrics, I mas mesmerized the way he puts words together. I immediately asked a good friend who lives and breathes theatre what else I knew by Sondheim and he mentioned WWS - my first thought (and thus my first words) were 'Officer Krupke!'
The OP needs a curriculum in musical theatre. -
friendoffilm — 10 years ago(November 27, 2015 10:41 AM)
NO it doesn't
You sir are an idiot and don't know what you're talking about. - with all due respect
This was perfection and should be left alone
No one could do it justice today or tomorrow
It's agreedthe film
West Side Story
is
in a special class all by itself and
should
be left alone. But is it really necessary to do all that name-calling that you've been doing? This is a forum where people come to discuss and even disagree with one another on certain movies, and it's quite natural sometimes for debates to get somewhat heated, but when it crosses over into name-calling and flaming, then it's out of boundsand unacceptable. -
friendoffilm — 10 years ago(January 04, 2016 08:21 AM)
This:
The music in this film is as great as it gets. And that's coming from a died-in-the-wool rock n roll fan. The West Side Story soundtrack is an all-time classic.
is absolutely spot-on, RickkVee! I, too am a rock-n-roll fan (especially of the Beatles1), but it's agreed that
West Side Story,
overall, from the music on down through the story behind this great classic, is a really beautiful film. My all time favorite, hands down! -
cheeso65 — 10 years ago(January 12, 2016 10:17 PM)
Needs a serious re-make
That's the dumbest idea ever.
The music blows
No, it's classic, timeless.
a gritty, urban endeavor. Long as they don't ghetto
Maybe you don't know what the words gritty and urban mean, particularly when used together. And the story is set in the ghetto, it's already ghetto-ed up. -
friendoffilm — 10 years ago(January 13, 2016 08:23 PM)
Way to go, cheeso65! The great, golden oldie-but-keeper 1961 classic film,
West Side Story
needs a "serious re-make" like a hole in the head, if one gets the drift.
if Steve Spielberg has any common sense, and as much affection for the film
West Side Story
as he claims that he does, he'll leave well enough alone, and not even
think
of messing with a classic! -
bluesouptin — 9 years ago(April 14, 2016 09:28 PM)
Agreed, cheeso65. In fact, I believe WWS finds its grittiness in the phenomenon of delinquent youth gangs, emergent in the mid-1950s, and prominent on the Upper West side of Manhattan (Spanish Harlem). Interestingly, some say that the story originated as a Romeo & Juliet re-cast set in Manhattan's Lower East Sidethe combatant gangs, Catholics and Jews. Essentially, East Side Story!
But here's a question a friend once raised: Inasmuch as the story mines the tension of socially forbidden love, what better polarity in 1961 than that between black and white? And to spike the southern (and northern) outrage, cast Tony and the Jets as black and Mary (Maria) and the Sharks as poor whites, and watch the sparks of miscegenation fly! [Consider that, in WSS, for all the cultural disassociation depicted, no real
color
difference exists between Tony and Maria, nor much between the Jets and the Sharks, in truth. Yet, color matters as one of America's true markers of "otherness." Casting directors well know this.]
With black Jets and white Sharks, and all the racial hatred of 1961 thrown atop the production, many would have agreed with Anita's plea to Maria to "find one of her own kind." Of course, film producers of the era would never have attempted such a casting. Why? Because they knew their audiences and would have believed, rightly, in the unpalatability of a "black/white" casting. Such a main casting would have trouble, even today, more's the pity. -
jschillig — 9 years ago(April 14, 2016 07:25 PM)
I wouldn't mind a new adaptation, if it's done well. I mean, why do we see different stage productions of the same play or musical, if not to see what different directors and actors can bring out of it?
But I think I'd rather see it done as a live television musical. Most of the ones they've done so far have been rather lightheartedit would be a bit of a change to see them do a serious one with more serious themes for a change.