I was beyond offended.
-
queerever — 13 years ago(June 09, 2012 08:29 PM)
PS. I tend to try to avoid clichs, but you really are smart enough to get into serious trouble, but no smarter. "Ham-fisted attempt at a profound movie" - the sinister and piss weak nature of that line didn't sink in till a bit later. You, trying to be smart, criticising someone who has made a fabulous film, maybe #1 of all time to explicitly explore the horror of war. Get back on yr Yankee c ok (no matter where you're from) - I know, war films should glorify white people getting even, to be good - is that it? Not a real question, someone like you only answers from falsehoods anyway.
-
-
stussisluss — 15 years ago(January 18, 2011 04:42 PM)
I too made a chuckle or two when watching this with some friends, I think mostly it's a natural reaction to the film being so disturbing. At the end though, I can assure there were no laughs heard anywhere by any of us.
-
sammythemc — 15 years ago(January 23, 2011 02:15 PM)
It could be a defense mechanism, it could be genuine cold-heartedness, or it could just be that the laugher wasn't sucked into the movie like others were. Some people don't have the ability to suspend their disbelief and become emotionally involved in a film. By that I mean they never stop to think of the characters as real people, just as characters, so instead of seeing a bunch of bodies next to a house and thinking "That was the experience of many real people in the real world," they see a bunch of actors laying on top of one another in the nude, which is indeed a little absurd. Certain moments in this movie, devoid of context or sometimes because of it, are very bizarre (that weird mammal on the SS colonel's shoulder comes to mind), and some people laugh at bizarre things.
-
Dantu00e8s — 15 years ago(February 02, 2011 08:24 AM)
And why are they idiots? Because they don't like this movie? Or because they're not sympathizing enough with the character?
If it's the former, you're an elitist, pretentious ass (like most others on this board what is it about this movie?). If it's the latter, that's a trite observation. I'll put it to you: Did you like Armageddon? or Crank? Did you laugh at them? Well, I bet you wouldn't if you were going through what those characters were going through!
That sounds stupid, right? Well, it's no less valid than your point. It only seems less because of this absurd conviction that this movie is "important." And that makes people overlook how trite this movie really is and how it can fail to connect with people. -
Dantu00e8s — 15 years ago(February 04, 2011 07:27 AM)
Mac, just wanted to let you know I didn't read your "response." Over time on these threads, you've proven that you have nothing more to offer than juvenile insults and emoticons, because your ego can't handle me criticizing this movie. A couple of people have managed intelligent counterpoints and I like debating with them. Intelligent people can handle criticism, especially considering that it's of a movie, is completely subjective and they have no personal stake in it.
You have nothing worth saying.