Why do so many Yanks have trouble with this film?
-
filmtenk — 12 years ago(June 02, 2013 07:16 AM)
It's true my country has a lot of uneducated, uninformed people. But it also has some of the brightest. I have been watching films/tv with subtitles for years. Even English speaking movies, With English subtitles. I watch a lot of foreign films as well, never dubbed, just subtitles. So it's not beyond everyone in USA.
-
GuyOnTheLeft — 10 years ago(November 06, 2015 07:44 PM)
I'm a "Yank" and gave it a 9. I also am well aware that it was the Soviets that did the lion's share of work beating the Germans. (They didn't do their share in the Pacific though.)
My top 250:
http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250 -
som1950 — 9 years ago(December 03, 2016 10:44 PM)
The composite US rating of 7.4 is lower than the non-US 8.4, though 7.4 is not a negative rating.
The movie is about Belarus partisans, not the Red Army. I think the movie is too long with the immolation going on too long and the newsreels (some running backward) as Florya shoots the "Hitler Liberator" framed picture over and over and over and over is unnecessary.
I wonder how the small band of partisans managed to ambush the SS unit, most of whom are dead before the advocate of Slav genocide holds forth.
I think that Tarkovsky's (1962) "My Name Is Ivan" was plenty harrowing and less propagandistic,and MUCH shorter! -
jdcdsv — 12 years ago(June 30, 2013 02:06 AM)
What do you base your premise that Yanks have a problem with this film on? The film has an 8.2 rating on IMDB which is composed primarily of Americans. Which strongly indicates that most Yanks who have seen this film liked it.
-
Lyndhen — 12 years ago(June 30, 2013 05:49 AM)
http://www.imdb.com/board/10091251/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt
primarily non US actually - only one in four are US.
US users vote significantly lower - 7.2 vs 8.4
in fact 20% of US give it a one. Only 3% of non US do. -
ricardstuff — 12 years ago(July 21, 2013 01:20 AM)
- What if these are some vote-bots to downvote this movie, so that another movie takes its place in the Top250.
Maybe to promote the other movie's box office or other sales. (e.g. Inglorious Basterds) - Or maybe it is some of these crazy boycotts / "social activisms", which target this movie, because it is not against abortions. Those strange phenomenons seem to originate and spread in the US most often.
- Maybe it's the "US makes the best movies!!!! So I must downvote non-US movies"-mentality.
- Or maybe it is "I like it. But I think it should be an 8 and not an 8.3, so I give it a 1 to affect it more"
- What if these are some vote-bots to downvote this movie, so that another movie takes its place in the Top250.
-
jdcdsv — 12 years ago(November 05, 2013 12:47 PM)
7.2 is a positive review. That indicates that most Americans didn't have a problem with the movie but in fact liked it quite a bit. The premise of this thread is false. Most Yanks do not have a problem with this film.
-
-
JackBluegrass — 12 years ago(August 05, 2013 05:37 PM)
This film describes fighting between two of the worst governments on the planet at the time. After the war, one became better and the other got even worse.
The photography was beautiful, so I gave it 7/10. -
JackBluegrass — 12 years ago(November 09, 2013 09:04 AM)
jm,
Nearly all (educated) Americans know that the USA was at most a bit player in the European theatre of WW2.
Your opinion is not even wrong.
For your own safety, I advise not sharing that opinion with an American WWII vet who lost many fellow soldiers, Marines, army air corps, and naval personnel in European fighting. -
OldSamVimes — 11 years ago(May 02, 2014 07:59 PM)
The Communist rap sheet with 100-150 million dead is unsurpassed and unequaled.
The human race has killed
far
more than that, and you're a member of that group.
Next time we will be carving up Russia instead. Like it was supposed to be in the first place, and would have been all for the better.
Hope you get your war sometime buddy, maybe you'll get to mow down some Russian kids so they won't grow up into stinking commies that you'll have to kill later.
Don't forget to smear some blood on your face so you can feel like a man for about 5 minutes. -
looking4ahandout — 11 years ago(August 17, 2014 07:35 PM)
I'm a "Yank" and like this film quite a bit.
The o.p.'s interest in the cinema tastes of American viewers is not uncommon amongst some (often times from the UK) who seem to obsess over what we like and don't like (more appropriately what they believe we like and don't like). Note the assumptions he made based upon his own skewed beliefs. -
kb-kid3 — 10 years ago(May 24, 2015 12:50 PM)
Actually, US-based viewers gave this film a lower-than-average iMDB score, although there is no basis to formulate a reason why.
Writer, founder, editor, and webmaster: filmreviews12.com