The reason people hate Marisa Tomei's Oscar win…
-
mikainen — 17 years ago(September 03, 2008 12:00 PM)
I have no complaints her winning the Oscar. Your list on the other hand.
- She didnt star in a movie about gays
How many Oscar-winning movies are there that are about gays? 3? - She didnt cry
She was angry though, sure mark for Oscar-fishing. - She didnt speak in a British accent
Yes, Meryl Streeps trademark. - No one had AIDS in the movie
But what about the crew, grips and sound engineers? - More than 5 people went to see the film
Nearly as many as Titanic. - It was a movie that made people laugh
You have something here. Oscar-winning comedies after 1960:
The Apartment
Forrest Gump
The Sting (comedy/crime)
Tom Jones
and few actor-winners from comedies. - She didnt pretend to be a man
This is actually a huge Oscar-winning category. - She had the nerve to appear in a movie that appealed to a wide audience
Like Helen Hunt, bit**es. - She didnt star in a movie that preached to people about a social issue
Yes, like mafiosos money-making troubles or the use of hobbits as vehicles for saving the world. - The Coen Bros, Paul Thomas Anderson, or whatever other artsy fartsy director didnt direct it.
Or like in the good old days, Billy "Artie" Wilder. Even Eastwood has gone artsy.
Maybe I'll watch Big Lebowski for the umpteenth time right away. I love that fancy artistic elevating feeling I get watching Jeff Bridges head dumped into the toilet.
Ok, I had too much time sitting here with the flu.
- She didnt star in a movie about gays
-
GTizzle — 12 years ago(July 22, 2013 11:19 AM)
What a dumb*ss, hater response. Freakin' tool.
Don't even want to waste my 5 seconds explaining this to you, but.sigh.since you so obviously missed the OP's point: it's not that she didn't fall into ONE of the 10 categories the OP listed, but that she didn't fall into ANY of them. So nitpicking on each one meant nothing- it's the fact that ALL 10 applied in SOME WAY.
Go away hater.
Thank you for your time. -
ceebeegee — 17 years ago(February 13, 2009 03:42 PM)
- More than 5 people went to see the film
It's funny 'cause it's true.
Marisa completely deserved her win. In general I get annoyed with tiresome people who try to demean someone's victory, or worse, try to claim that everyone feels the same way. The honor is in the nomination, since the Academy votes at large for the actual award, but only your peers can nominate you. (That is, actors nominate actors; but the whole Academy votes for the eventual winner.) This is why there are so many boring, obvious choices, and why it's usually a dramawhich is annoying because comedy is much more diffuclt that drama.
- More than 5 people went to see the film
-
edorapietrafesa — 16 years ago(April 07, 2009 08:46 AM)
i remember the controversy and i absolutely thought she deserved it. she is soooo funny in this and steals the movie. because it was more low budget and the stars hadn't been seen in awhile (pesci, macchiocharacter actors..herman munster), people assumed the meryl streep types would win. well, this girl got it and deserved it and i'm proud of her. she earned it. thank god they let a comedic actress win who isn't pretentious or full of crap.
-
ragusa11 — 16 years ago(April 10, 2009 06:19 PM)
People don't think of comedy as "Oscar caliber" is what it boils down to it.
She easily stuck out in a weak year. There are years where everyone in the category deserves it but only one person/film gets the award.
I remember when Silence of the Lambs won best picture. There is NO WAY that movie was Oscar Caliber. Excellent movie but that year was so weak. I think Beauty and the Beast by Disney was it's main competition that year. -
vilj-1 — 16 years ago(February 22, 2010 03:37 PM)
I know you posted your comment in 2008, but I recommend that you read it again and edit it. Some of the things you wrote are "unbelievable," to say the least. Do yourself a favor. Reconsider, delete and repost. For the record, I am a big fan of Marisa Tomei. She has proven to be a great actress and she totally deserved the Oscar for this film. Her performance in "The Wrestler" was outstanding.