Why did Karla think they were HER tickets?
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
Prince911 — 14 years ago(July 28, 2011 01:25 PM)
After they answer the radio question right Karla teases Julie about who she's gonna give
her
tickets to. And later when Ray doesn't show up, Karla says she invited Will because she didn't want
her
ticket to go to waste.
This irritates me because not only did the radio show host (
Will
) call Julie's phone, but Julie was also the one to answer the question for Karla. She went in the cupboard grabbed the coffee and gave Karla the answer.
So just because Karla's using Julie's phone when the radio guy called, and yes it was Julie's phone because when the phone rings Julie says "My number's unlisted", she thinks the tickets are hers and she gets decide what to do with them?
I realize this is the most trivial thing to complain about and there are many more ridiculous aspects of this film to complain about, but that just always bugged me.
You wish it was Ted! Don't forget to set the alarm -
SeleneGoddess — 14 years ago(October 25, 2011 01:25 PM)
Julie lived alone. They weren't roommates. If they were, I doubt Julie would have been suspicious at the beginning of the movie when Karla was there looking for Julie's skirt. Julie was woken up by the door closing and walked through the apartment with a knife. If Karla was her roommate, I doubt she would have been
that
suspicious at the front door closing.
Arguing with a bigot is like teaching an infant the quadratic formula. -
JCrewgirl — 14 years ago(November 02, 2011 03:07 PM)
Yes they were. Carla lived there or at least she acted like she did, she was doing her laundry, answering the phone, etc. that sounds like someone who lives there not just visiting.
"Behind every woman scorned is a man that made her that way"
"Baggage Claim" by Miranda Lambert -
SeleneGoddess — 14 years ago(November 02, 2011 03:09 PM)
- Julie would not have reacted the way she did at the
front door closing
if she had a roommate who would have come in through the front door. - Julie says it's "her number" that's unlisted. Not "our number".
- Friends do laundry at each other's places all the time. Especially if they went home with them after a night at the club. Not to mention that all Carla washed were her tennis shoes. It's not like she had heaps of laundry she was washing.
Arguing with a bigot is like teaching an infant the quadratic formula.
- Julie would not have reacted the way she did at the
-
EmilyTheDramaQueen — 14 years ago(November 02, 2011 04:21 PM)
- Julie's been through hell and back so she's paranoid and judging from the class room scene she freaks out A LOT!
- They can have different land lines like me and my roommate do
Also, every description of this movie says that Carla is her roommate, so I don't get why your stupid ass (and you are the only one who does) think they aren't. So get over it they are!
-
SeleneGoddess — 14 years ago(November 02, 2011 06:20 PM)
Actually, if you read our posts, it was more laughter and joking on my part (and I think her part) where I didn't appreciate the childish nature she responded with and she thought I couldn't admit I was wrong. Then it just ended up beingfluff
If only closed minds came with closed mouths.