There was a post were some said he was and some said no. Where in the movie does it say he is guilty, since I thought h
-
tbeller80 — 15 years ago(January 06, 2011 05:06 AM)
Ask the mechanic. If one of my employees commits a crime, that shouldn't automatically condemn everyone in the business. The police would be in their rights to bring everyone in for questioning, but Tariq was brought in and tortured to death.
-
filip54 — 13 years ago(April 08, 2012 03:58 AM)
The point was that it didn't matter if he was guilty or not, the terrorist had already won because of how the americans were approaching the problem; i.e. torture. Like Denzel says, he doesn't know who the cells are, yet they torture and murder him anyway, so the evil aparatus has already taken a on a life of it's own. That, beside the point that he had a right to fair trail and all.
-
sage2112 — 10 years ago(February 28, 2016 01:48 AM)
Ya know I just don't buy the notion that the terrorists win just because we are scared or whatever. Of course we are, it's fight or flight. I hope it never comes to martial law but if it does, it does.
It's never really win or lose, just a constant flux of different states of readiness, action, etc.