leah definitely should have been the killer in c minor. much better motive as a murderer
-
Sk8str — 12 years ago(January 04, 2014 09:32 PM)
Debut- It seemed too random and I liked him too much.
I do agree with the previous poster that once you get used tot he pattern of the show you can pick out the doer 80% of the time. The ones I usually end up having no clue in are the ones that were not actually murders.
"So, you wrote a bad play and were molested, welcome to the theatre." -
kdogg369 — 12 years ago(January 12, 2014 12:01 PM)
I agree with you about Debut. I'm sorry but several of the other girls had much stronger motives then he did.
As for being able to figure out the doer,pretty much the case with any crime show after a while,the patterns become really easy to pick up,even on shows like CSI and NCIS I can figure out who the bad guys are early on. -
fairyqueen — 11 years ago(July 17, 2014 10:26 PM)
I agree with most of your choices Jacksonepling! I don't really remember Who's Your Daddy but what you said makes sense. I made a similar point earlier about Beautiful Little Fool. Who would you have preferred to be the killer in Colors and Beautiful Little Fool?
-
HumanFundRecipient — 11 years ago(July 19, 2014 02:32 PM)
The episode Ravaged comes to mind- yeah, I had to look it up. Anyway, the one frat boy staying at the bar trying to hook up with victim despite her being an alcoholic. At least her dog had enough sense between them to not let that happen.
Are we beginning to see the possibilities here? -
fairyqueen — 11 years ago(July 20, 2014 12:22 PM)
Those two choices for Colors make sense. I already knew who the killer was when I watched that episode and I was disappointed that it was him. He seemed likeable. I agree that the motivation was weak.
I guess you read what I wrote about Beautiful Little Fool? Your ideas are good. I like the idea of Violet being a little bit bad (but not completely). I think if Felix had killed her because of blackmail, he still would have looked kind of bad (especially because she had a baby) but it would have made more sense. -
fairyqueen — 11 years ago(July 20, 2014 08:38 PM)
"mickey stein? why should he have killed violet? because of carmela le fleur?"
Yes, that was my idea. I thought he could have killed Violet because he saw her as a threat to Carmela's happiness. He seemed very devoted to her. I think it's at least a better idea than what the episode actually did. -
christianturba4 — 11 years ago(July 27, 2014 03:30 PM)
don't agree about true calling, very good episode with a likeable victim and the relationshoip between laura and renaldo..the most obvious choice would've been the other teacher, margaret..and renaldo of course..