Capote VS Infamous
-
KyrKyr — 16 years ago(August 15, 2009 03:41 AM)
When i saw this movie for first time i like it so much that i couldnt forget it. It was one of the greatest performances by an actor, very difficult in diracting and very sad.
I saw first Infamous and i didnt like it but when i saw Capote i put it straight in my Top 20 favorite movies. -
DianneBellmont — 13 years ago(January 13, 2013 05:58 PM)
I saw Infamous first, then Capote a half hour later. As much as I adore Hoffman and admire his work as an actor, I preferred Infamous.
Capote was plodding and didn't keep my attention. The script, music and sets were far superior with Infamous.
As a side note, I adore Sandy Bullock, but I think Catherine Keener nailed the part of Nelle Harper Lee in Capote.
*The Manitou is in and will take your calls now. -
-
rdeschene — 16 years ago(March 22, 2010 07:06 AM)
Having watched "Capote" again last night, and "Infamous" a week ago, I feel that "Capote" is the better film, from an artistic standpoint. Nearly every aspect of it is perfect. But I also felt that, as brilliant as Philip Seymour Hoffman was in this role, and as much as he completely transformed himself, I didn't find it completely believable that people would have been as enthralled by him as they were. I thought that Toby Jones did a better job of getting that charisma across.
But, having said that, I think the respective points of boths films were different. "Capote" seemed to be about showing the inner downward spiral created by Capote's decision to manipulate Perry to get his story, and to pretend that he'd done all he could to keep them from being executed, when in reality he'd done nothing of the sort. It appears that decision was, in the end, Capote's own undoing. On the other hand, "Infamous" seemed more about the craft of writing, and what a writer like Capote did in his relationships with people to tweak and bend the truth to suit his own desired narrative. He seemed to be more of a compulsive liar here than the master manipulator "Capote" made him out to be. "Infamous"'s telling of the story, too, had disastrous consequences for Capote, as he found himself caught in a relationship with Perry over which he seemed to have very little control (very different from how "Capote" presented it).
After watching "Infamous" last week, my initial feeling was that I liked it better, if only because the performances were a bit more accessible, the writing had more of a natural (if predictable) narrative flow. It's hard not to contrast the two films, given how closely together they came, but they are two remarkably different presentations of essentially the same story . . . just as two different eyewitnesses will often present two very different recollections of what they saw.
As amazing an actor as he is, Hoffman has a way of making his characters seem insular and emotionally isolated from others, whereas Jones was more convincing to me in his interactions with others. He seemed far more emotionally engaged, and engaging . . . even if half of what he said was pure fiction. But I found myself believing more that people could fall for what he said, than I did with Hoffman's portrayal.
It's hard not to contrast the two performances of Nelle Harper Lee. Again, very different takes on the same character. Catherine Keener is more hard as nails; she has a quiet dignity, yet also has a wild streak of humor and fierce determination that give her the most moral authority of anyone in the film. Sandra Bullock, on the other hand, was a pleasant surprise. For once, I didn't feel like I was watching Sandra Bullock, but a character. Through her character, she perfectly articulates the anguish that comes with being a writer. It's a side of the craft that few understand . . . even those who have been there. Her deft sensitivity also shines through in her attempts to understand and explain her friendship with Capote. Interesting echo from the story: I found myself wishing she could have been my friend.
Daniel Craig's portrayal of Perry Smith was absolutely riveting (as was that of Clifton Collins, though in a much quieter, more subtle way). I found Perry's growing trust in Capote quite believable in "Infamous" because the foundation for it was more compelling, somehow. It made sense to me, again, even if the details presented are complete fiction. I guess that's the point of trying to understand Truman Capote; how much of what we know of the man is fact, how much fiction? How much of his writing is truth, how much of it spun from his imagination? I doubt that there will ever be a definitive answer to that question. Both films have a different take on that. In "Infamous," it's the developing relationship, and how that forces Capote to change his game plan, that is the focus, whereas in "Capote," it's how Capote manipulates Perry to get what he wants.
In the end, both films are superb wonderings of what drove Capote to be the way he was. -
Vergilya — 15 years ago(July 07, 2010 05:48 AM)
I still say it's Infamous. I don't know which one is closer to the truth or which one better represents Truman for who he really was. From the way the story is told Infamous is more enjoyable and the development of the characters are beautifully captured. Capote is a little more bland and dry and doesn't really get into the heart and soul of the characters. I would have preferred Toby Jones to win the Oscar, but then again - That's Hollywood.
-
gioconda — 15 years ago(August 07, 2010 11:54 PM)
I hung out w/Truman Capote several times.
Nearly impossible to describe. So over the top, brilliant, brave, unacceptably intoxicated, outspoken, ruthlessly witty & hilarious. Loved his special cache & "in" w/wives of the uber rich & famous, as he dragged a grizzly butch Irishman around everywhere, whom he adored, hard-drinking married truck driver & father of 7 kids. What a couple. Truman wore huge white and pastel women's straw hats w/giant sashes & gigantic sunglasses. At 4' 11" the impression was an elfish insect in drag.
Toby Jones' portrayal of him is more like the actual person than PSH.
Both "Infamous" & Capote" are worth a look. Both lead actors are brilliant. I was disappointed in the female leads. Sandra Bullock & Catherine Keener were both so-so, particularly Sandra's attempt at a Southern accent. Both sets of killers in the two films were very good. Daniel Craig stood out as Perry.
However, the most spine-tingling portrayal of Perry is Robert Blake in the original "In Cold Blood". Mindboggling & indelible. Check it out. -
mimosa_mirabella — 15 years ago(September 12, 2010 06:42 AM)
Infamous is the better movie. Toby Jones was amazing.
http://vincentandmorticiasspeakeasy14846.yuku.com/directory] -
Bozo275 — 15 years ago(February 03, 2011 10:15 PM)
You know what Hoffman thought Truman Capote should be? And you know for a fact that Toby Jones what was Capote was like?
The ideas presented in In Cold Blood and the book Capote both present this idea that Capote, as an idea is fluid, open to interpretation. Capote, by most records, was not an overwhelming evil man. Phillip Seymour Hoffman does not portray him as an evil man, just unfeeling, and disconnected.
Capote was far more darker than Infamous, and for this I give it the thumbs up. The filming is elegant, dark and yet minimalist. A great piece of cinematography, and I think Bennet Miller, the director is owed far more credit than he recieves. Capote's tone far better suits the tone of In Cold Blood, and this is why Infamous did not strike me as a particularly suitable tone.
Both Jones and Bullock are far too light for such a subject.
Capote all the way! -
Nightrider2 — 14 years ago(November 26, 2011 09:51 AM)
I liked Capote much better. While Toby Jones resembled real author there was something unpleasant about his portrayal. Hoffman seemed more genuine. Clifton Collins Jr. also did a terrific job as Perry Smith. Daniel Craig was all wrong as Smith, plus Infamous was overstuffed with famous actors which was extremely distracting.It was like big show piece. On the other hand Capote was a quiet, stylish character study. It was simply a better film.
http://www.youtube.com/user/viclis11?feature=mhee