You're Jeff: Who Would You Save/Forgive?
-
cj_sutton14 — 16 years ago(April 07, 2009 08:45 PM)
I'd probably save the lady, cause she did nothing wrong. She was only scared.
I'd probably let the judge die, but then again, I wouldn't want to watch the poor guy die. So I'd save himif I was Jeff though, let him go.
And the drunkI'd try and save him, cause thats a messed up death.
And Jigsaw.I'd save him, cause he gave me a chance to approach the people who messed up and what not.
My Dear Albert Wesker. I Doubt Your Even Dead, But Until Than. R.I.P -
rterrell23 — 16 years ago(June 02, 2009 09:40 PM)
I would have saved them all no problem. It sucks that my son would have died but I really wouldn't be able to live with myself knowing I played a part in the murder of innocent people. Yes they are innocent because by law they did not commit a crime and Timothy served his sentence. Afterwards I would let them know I am still upset and mournful but they are free to go. And the girl would be meeting with me shortly thereafter with knee pads haha.
-
RobBase086-1 — 16 years ago(September 30, 2009 01:46 PM)
I would have forgiven as well because if not then you have committed a sin right there for letting the person just die like that.
Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show!
www.deefilmroll.com/usa-uan/ -
fifithedestroyer — 16 years ago(October 02, 2009 11:00 AM)
the moral delima is that jeffs son was killed, not murdered.
murder requires intent. a child accidently hit, while tragic is not murder.
which means anyone jeff let die was a choice with intent. makeing him worse than any of those individuals, especially if he allowed his lust for vengance be the motivation.
the only real exception to the above is jigsaw. -
RobBase086-1 — 16 years ago(October 06, 2009 10:35 AM)
You are correct about that it was an accident that his son was killed. Yes Jigsaw is the only exception but still he is the one who is setting this all up though.
Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show!
www.deefilmroll.com/usa-uan/ -
HeurekaH — 16 years ago(October 11, 2009 01:15 PM)
I want to say that I would let them all die. If I were in Jeffs situation I would like to see them all dead. I am well aware of the pain in loosing a child in a manner like that, though it was not my own child. I know the pain and dispair that Jeff went through. Had it been just a year or two since the childs death I would do absolutely nothing. But after some time you learn to live with it. But had I been in Jeffs mental state, still very much instable I would have definetly let them all die!
But really, when they all started shouting "I dind't do you anything", "save me" and beep like that I would probably end up doing nothing anyway. What is that? Like the witness, "I didn't do you anything". Thats the problem. SO, the more they talk to me and the more they try to convince me not let them die,I would problably just end up telling them to beep off and look at them die or crawl up in a corner och close my eye and cover my ears and try not to notice as they scream of fear and agony! -
RobBase086-1 — 16 years ago(October 13, 2009 02:26 PM)
I would have tried to at least do something to help them out of the trap. I mean I would expect the same thing if I was in that situation myself.
Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show!
www.deefilmroll.com/usa-uan/ -
MaraudersFan — 15 years ago(July 31, 2010 11:38 AM)
I would have tried to save them all. It would have been nice if the man had gotten more then 6months but in this society it does not always happen. It was also right when someone said the time this man was thrown in prison would not have really consoled them at all, unless he got life in prison and if this was his first offense very unlikely that would have happened, which also explains the light sentence. From Timothys flashbacks he was truly broken up by it. Jigsaw was right his life was changed that day just like that little boys family. He probably thought of Dylan every single day, wishing that it had not happened. He likely needed tons of therapy, Could have even made him change his life for the better. Recently I read a story in readers digest of a man in his 30s who accidently killed a girl (15) when he was about 17, now he wasnt drunk. The girl on her bike was just suddenly there. He says how it took him years and years to deal with it and even decades later he is still dealing with it. This game shows exactly how hard it is to forgive others. But even harder then forgiving others is to learn to forgive ourselves.
The women in the freezer, she made a mistake but we all make mistakes. Even if she had testify I doubt he'd have gotten more then maybe 5 years and probably would have seen possible parole at about 3 years.
Lastly Id have done it because I believe that no one will pass before their time. I know a lot of people dont like hearing that. However we were not all meant to pass on at a very elderly age. It be nice if everyone died a peaceful death but that does not always happen either.
Vengeance or prolonged hatred (which can become internal poisons) rarely get anyone anything. All one does is spread the hurt and pain because this people (who died) also had families, parents, cousins, children, friends etc. Who would all be effected by their deaths just like Jeff and Lynn (and even their daughter) were effected by their sons death. -
RobBase086-1 — 15 years ago(August 01, 2010 08:50 PM)
Very interesting and profound with all of the information that you are telling me about the film and similar instances that have happened to people in the film or outside of it. You are correct about vengeance and hate being a poison that does not help solve anything at all.
USA UP ALL NIGHT petition!
www.petitiononline.com/moviefan/petition.html -
LuckyMatt93 — 16 years ago(October 14, 2009 04:22 PM)
I would only save Halden. He was innocent and only did his duty as a judge. Danica was a cold (ironic, eh?), heartless, and despicable monster who deserved to die. Timothy would be the cause for all of my pain and suffering in the first place because he made the stupid and irresponsible choice to drink and drive. I would have let him die too.
"You don't know what death is"-Sam Loomis (Halloween 2) -
Horror_Movie_Lover_Bot — 15 years ago(August 18, 2010 03:07 PM)
Well if I was Jeff (which I never would be since I hate kids and I would never want one of my own.)
I would let them all live. No hard feeling, since a death of a child wouldn't mean much to me. -
ezchoice — 15 years ago(September 21, 2010 07:50 AM)
I'm not religious but in that situation I would save them all. Whether or not I actually forgave someone I had those feelings toward is somthing else.
Jeff had to be the worst character in the entire series. I mean how weak is one expected to be? Bad things happen in life, that's a fact. Letting someone freeze to death at the hands of a serial killer is about as low as it gets in terms of lows.
The first time I watched Saw III I cringed at Jeff's base and useless self. After re-watching it (not sure why since it really was an awful movie but I am a horror fan) I was actually glad to see that his wife was cheating on him, the only problem was that she should have told him to go to hell while she was dying.
The movie could have been decent if they had thought of a more sinister motivation behind his son's death. -
mfentruck — 14 years ago(September 12, 2011 01:47 AM)
I really can't comprehend how so many people would have just let them die. That's a little creepy to me.
I couldn't just sit there while someone was being tortured to death if I had an opportunity to save them. I just couldn't do it. -
johnc11982 — 14 years ago(October 10, 2011 01:45 PM)
The thing to remember is, it's not as simple as flipping a switch and then the person lives, or grabbing a key off a table and unlocking them. To save them, he had to rip a bit off of his face, burn the last physical things he has to remember his dead son by, and take a bullet. He has no obligation to do any of those things, and thus isn't "responsible" for the peoples' death even if he chooses not to do them.
Jigsaw, on the other hand, he had to actively kill. "Saving" him merely meant refraining from killing him. And since Jigsaw posed no imminent threat (and actually offered a way out - "I can have an ambulance here in four minutes"), to refrain from killing him IS an obligation.
I'm actually not sure which ones I would save and wouldn't save. But I could only really be called wrong for "not saving" Jigsaw.