Is Eli Manning the most overrated QB in history?
-
weststigersbob — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 08:04 PM)
Overrated ? Hardly. If he mentioned in the same bracket as Montana, Elway, Favre, Young, Brady etc, then yeah. But I've never seen him put in that bracket of QB's.
I think he's an above average QB whose won two SB's and he's done enough in his career to justify being called a good QB. He will never be an "all time great" or a "GOAT", but he's achieved more than most QBs ever will.
http://tinyurl.com/5o5apv -
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 08:09 PM)
When have I ever said Cam is great? Show me, I haven't. Cam isn't great. He's a good QB but not a great one, he's not elite either. However he did have a great year last year with less talent at receiver than Eli has. If he was the QB of the Giants he would do a better job than Eli and they would score more points instead of winning through their defense like they've done this year.
-
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 08:44 PM)
You won't answer because you are a lying little bitch like your friend Hairy. I've never said Cam Newton is great, that was NTDT. And you know I am not NTDT but you are lying and trying to make me a Panthers fan who says Newton is great, and you know you can't attribute NTDT's quotes to me or you will be looking really stupid, so you are backing out and running away like a pussy.
-
jimanchower — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 08:58 PM)
Loutell you what.you go through every post you've made here for the last 10 months and get back to me, because I'm sure not going to.
Besides you already deleted the account where you did most of your Cam worship. -
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 09:24 PM)
And here we go with the claim that I'm NTDT. What is your proof of that? That we both did Play by Play threads and we both dislike Andrew Luck and the Colts? You are ignoring the numerous differences between us, he was a Panthers fan while I've never cared one way or the other for them, I have never made one post where I said I was a Panthers fan, he hated the Pats I like them, he loved Duke I hate them, he didn't like baseball I am a big fan, he posted on the politics board I don't, I post about TV shows he didn't, and I can go on and on. But you are obsessed with proving we are the same person because we both believe that your boy Luck is an overrated TO machine. That and doing the play by play threads are our only similarity.
-
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 09:39 PM)
All of the things that I just mentioned are proof that I'm not him.
I could give you my address in South Florida where I live and you could come visit me and I would show you my account in person, but for all I know you are a serial killer or a master thief and I would be better off avoiding you. After all, what is the proof that you aren't a serial killer?
I shouldn't have to prove that I'm not another poster that I have 2 things in common with. You are an idiot.
What is the proof that you are not Hairy Butt Cheeks?
What is the proof you are not AH Fan?
What is the proof YOU are not NTDT or this "Luigi" that you are obsessed with? -
jimanchower — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 07:58 PM)
Those Giant teams got hot at exactly the right time. Manning isn't a great QB but he's very good and he played great during their two SB runs.
He threw 15TDs to two INTs during those 8 SB year playoff games. How much better could he have played? 5 out of those 8 games his rating was over 100.
The Op's just doing what the OP does.saying stupid sh it. -
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 08:38 PM)
He's not "very good". A very good QB doesn't throw 14+ picks every year except 2. He played well in the playoffs twice, he had a good team around him, his defense played very well also and the whole team got hot and won the Super Bowl. In the Super Bowl, they played very strong defense and got lucky. Eli didnt do much to help them win Super Bowl 42. The defense played great and held Brady to 14 points and they got the miracle Tyree catch and scored right afterwards to win. He played well in Super Bowl 46 but had Welker not dropped a wide open pass then the Pats would've won.
-
-
Xeliou66 — 9 years ago(December 23, 2016 09:18 PM)
How about his ton of interceptions and ton of lousy seasons where he missed the playoffs Jimanchower? He hasn't even been since 2011. Hardly elite. He's not even in the top 10 QB's in the league. He is a pampered elitist who got to go to a big time team because his daddy broke the rules and used influence to get him there, and the weak ass mainstream media gave him a pass. He has thrown more picks than any active QB except Brees who has played for 3 more years than him and Brees has only thrown 4 more picks. Eli is overrated, about as good as Troy Aikman who is similar as a QB on loaded teams who won multiple Super Bowls that he wasn't responsible for.