I came here to say exactly that. I watched Psycho last night and as soon as I saw him, it hit me. He is looking and talking exactly like Andrew Garfield.
"Losing all hope was freedom"
I have one word for you: Shane Carruth.
Okay, that's two words. I'm watching On the Beach now and he reminds me of Shane (Primer) - Donna Anderson looks surprisingly like Mary Elizabeth Winstead as well.
I have a crush on AP and I tried to convince myself to have a crush on AG because they had some similar features but I just couldn't. AP was tall and hot, his acting was so diverse. His eyes can go from menacing to soulful. It's not the same.