Monk is not a comedy
-
bill_the_galactic_hero — 18 years ago(October 04, 2007 07:45 AM)
In classic theater, the opposite of comedy is not drama. The opposite of comedy is tragedy. Both are forms of drama. In a drama, as in real life, there is conflict. In a tragedy, things end badly, often with the death of the hero(es). In a comedy, things end on an up note, if not happily. A show with the classic "Hollywood ending" would make it a comedy: "they rode off into the sunset," or "they all lived happily ever-after." Humor can play a role in either a comedy or a tragedy just as in the drama of real life.
Of course, neither the Emmys nor the Oscars, nor imdb use the classic meaning of the words comedy or drama for their genre classifications, so you could say that my point is moot. But, there it is for what it's worth. -
drjohnhwatson — 19 years ago(December 30, 2006 04:19 PM)
yeah monk can be funny at times n 3n thats why i like it. but it is more drama, like with my favorite episode; Mr Monk vs the cobra or whatever where's he b16d0uried alive and he's dying and he talks to trudy..
then too their categories never make sense. They shut out lost for chrissakes and put desperate housewives for comedy when it too should be drama. -
31073 — 21 years ago(August 16, 2004 09:20 AM)
Its not a "Sit-Com" (like say seinfeld) but its still a comedy.. My #1 favorite show on tv is "Scrubs"
(Monk is probably #2.) Now scrubs is about a bunch of intern's at a hospital.. People die every episode, sometimes its the main characters fault. The show swings from very sad and touching, to downright hysterical. Thats what great shows do. They find that balance of drama and comedy that makes it way over the top, but still believable.
ER= Drama
Scrubs = Comedy
CSI = Drama
Monk = Comedy -
Neona_sky — 19 years ago(August 28, 2006 05:17 PM)
Let me start off by saying,
Scrubs is simply AMAZING!!
Also, I agree with you on everything you said. Yeahthat covers it all.
Nicely put, 31073
"Two things are infinite-the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe." Albert Einstein -
Eyes_of_Emerald — 21 years ago(August 22, 2004 10:58 PM)
The5b4 season finale on Friday, August 20 was just hilarious. Monk's psychiatrist gives him a new medication to try for his OCD and it makes him "normal" again.if you could call it that. I won't go into details in case you haven't seen it yet, let's just say Monk was not "himself." The episode just totally cracked me up. And there were parts of the show that were pretty heart-wrenching. I LOVE Monk, I hope it's on for a long, long time.I think it's the best show on right now. As a matter of fact, it's the only show on network TV that I will watch.
Tongue tied and twisted, just an earthbound misfit, I -
MarvelGirlSixteen — 21 years ago(September 06, 2004 07:18 PM)
Being someone suffering from OCD, I think 'Monk' is truly hilarious. I'm only fourteen, and yet, I can relate to most everything his symptoms personify. This show makes me giggle unendingly at how he personifies the disorder.
Finding David Hewlett
: My next indie film project. -
rainleaf — 20 years ago(June 12, 2005 08:31 AM)
I think in a genre, Monk would be classified somewhere between a drama and a comedy. You can always disagree with its classification to a certain degree, and I'm sure you're right. But I personally feel that Monk doesn't reinforce mean-spirited humour towards those that suffer from an obsessive-compulsive disorder. I think bossanovachin's post sums this up in the best way: It infact, indirectly gains awareness about the disease and how dracastically it can change one's life; and the laughter saves you from isolation, and it makes it easier to let go.
-
katielu1218 — 20 years ago(September 19, 2005 03:10 PM)
it kind of is a comedy.. and it was nominated last year for an Emmy under "comedy" too. i think it kind of falls under "comedy/mystery"? its not really a drama but it does have drama some of the time.
katerrrsss
-
i_am_sabrina — 20 years ago(February 28, 2006 12:52 AM)
I agree. Monk is a great and funny show. I love how it focuses on Monk's brilliance because of his OCD, rather than his weirdness because of his OCD. But, I do agree. Monk gets pretty deep sometimes, and I like that. I enjoy laughing my head off, but I like to see that it's very grounded and senseable, too. Monk is a fantastic show.