Great movie, horrible music!
-
leadingrole344 — 10 years ago(February 23, 2016 11:45 PM)
The ancient Romans had a proverb, "De gustibus non est disputandem," i.e., "There's no arguing over taste." Someone who loves Wagner might despise Stravinsky, and vice-versa, but there's no point disputing who's right or wr ong. HOWEVER, the vast majority of people who know film scores have pointed to this one as being among the most creative and brilliantly evocative in the history of cinema, all accomplished with one table-held instrument. I'm in their camp.
-
laserfan — 10 years ago(March 13, 2016 01:30 PM)
After a while, I was (mostly) able to tune the "music" out, since it was so very repetitive, but I found it to be mostly hideous, out-of-place, and quite appalling.
Watched it for the first time last night on PBS (horrible print) and enjoyed it, obviously (or I wouldn't be here). It seems the film has been restored; I was hoping the restoration would ditch the crappy "soundtrack" (can a single tune be called a "soundtrack"?).
Cotton was suitably clueless, Valli achingly beautiful, Welles perfectly charming and creepy at the same time, and it was nice to see Trevor Howard and Bernard Lee in their early days!
Karas was no-doubt well-loved in Vienna, but it's clear from his listing here he got no other meaningful work from this Third Man effort. -
guccipix — 9 years ago(May 12, 2016 07:29 PM)
I think the score is probably the best thing about this wonderful film.
http://letterboxd.com/guccipix/list/my-top-100-favorite-films/ -
leadingrole344 — 9 years ago(June 01, 2016 02:51 AM)
Oxhan, you're naturally entitled to your opinion of the music in this movie. Yet it is such a rare one that it's akin to people who say they enjoy classical music but can't stand any of the German composers from Bach to Brahms.
-
dea-syria — 9 years ago(September 12, 2016 04:17 PM)
The soundtrack of the Third Man is perfect. But here is is what you do. You do your own cut, dubbing in music from whatever little teen-age dance band was topping the charts when you were in high-school (The Rolling Stones, Nirvana, NIN, etc., depending on how old you are) because I'm sure that the only kind of music you;re capable of understanding. Whatever you do, don't watch Bergman's Trollflotte.
-
jamesc-helgrim — 9 years ago(September 18, 2016 09:23 PM)
It's a stylistic choice designed to provide two things: first, an authentic Vienna atmosphere (the director found the composer playing zither in one of the bars seen in the film, actually); and second, to supplement the comedic and occasionally somewhat surreal elements and undertones used to offset the bleak story and themes. It fulfills its function incredibly well. Whether or not you like that function is a matter of personal choice. (For the record, I didn't really like it, but I'm a product of my time, just as is the film itself). But don't call it "stupid" or "a mistake." Doing so only shows that you're approaching the question superficially and without any thought or background research whatsoever.
-
jamesc-helgrim — 9 years ago(September 18, 2016 09:30 PM)
It's a stylistic choice designed to provide two things: first, an authentic Vienna atmosphere (the director found the composer playing zither in one of the bars seen in the film, actually); and second, to supplement the comedic and occasionally somewhat surreal elements and undertones used to offset the bleak story and themes. It fulfills its function incredibly well. Whether or not you like that function is a matter of personal choice. (For the record, I didn't really like it, but I'm a product of my time, just as is the film itself). But don't call it "stupid" or "a mistake." Doing so only shows that you're approaching the question superficially and without any thought or background research whatsoever.
-
Don-the-Lamplighter — 9 years ago(October 19, 2016 05:24 AM)
Initially, the "quirky" zither tune was interesting and off-beat. But there were 2 factors that took it from "different" to "annoying". At critical points, it just seemed to go off the rails, and it sounded like they handed a ukulele to an orangutan and just pressed "RECORD".
Then there was the repetition. The same 37 notes. Over. And over. And over. And over. And over. And over. And.
I thought "Beyond Tomorrow" recurred a lot in "Serpico". That was nothing.
The zither refrain in "The Third Man" made me long for a relaxing session of root canal with Edith Bunker yelling in my ear.
I challenge anybody who enjoyed this to obtain the soundtrack to this movie, and play it in their car for 1 hour. I guarantee you will drive off a bridge or into a telephone pole in the first 15 minutes. -
Wilde_2015 — 9 years ago(November 03, 2016 10:21 AM)
Again, I like the piece but it isn't that great when used within the movie. I bet someone could edit the audio in this movie very easily adding either traditional orchestral scoring or using popular music to make a better version of this movie.