why did they lobotomize McMurphy?
-
silverr8c — 9 years ago(September 27, 2016 11:13 PM)
The reason he tried to kill her was because he was overcome with grief knowing that she was directly responsible for the kids death.
Thomas Gibson has been fired from Criminal minds now I won't watch CM, No Hotch no watch -
kieranmufc1999 — 9 years ago(August 18, 2016 03:29 AM)
Ratchet couldn't control him and was loosing control of the ward because of him. She was the kind of person who has to have complete control and defeat anyone so by letting Mac out he would have defeated her whereas if he's lobotomised the people in the ward see she's defeated him
-
silverr8c — 9 years ago(September 27, 2016 12:13 AM)
There was another reason, FEAR.
She was afraid that if there was an investigation into the kids death Murphy would testify that he killed himself as a direct result of her attacking the kid psychologically by threatening to tell the young mans mother about his little adventure. The kids hear of being exposed made him kill himself. Her fear of being exposed as a sadistic manipulator by Murphy made her fix it so Murph could no longer talk.
Thomas Gibson has been fired from Criminal minds now I won't watch CM, No Hotch no watch -
znapper — 9 years ago(February 06, 2017 05:03 AM)
I don't find that very believable.
Any testimony from McMurphy would be laughable, since he is more or less nuts in the eyes of society.
It would be a bigger threat to her if any of the voluntary patients to leave and then speak of their experience, but she only lobotomized the only guy that could never leave.
No, he was lobotomized because she had all she needed to get it done and finally get rid of this problem once and for all, her only goal was control over the ward and the patients and that is also why she was so sickeningly happy after everything had settled down again.
She never cared for Billy and she never cared for any of her patients either, she even enjoyed seeing patients showing opposition, having a hard time, so she was sadistic as well.