In other words, she's not any of the other characters we see, if anything because the actress playing her does not play
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — Eyes Wide Shut
LetThemEatCake01 — 9 years ago(December 04, 2016 01:11 AM)
In other words, she's not any of the other characters we see, if anything because the actress playing her does not play any of the other female characters. There was speculation that she was Marion, the most common conclusion is that she is Mandy but she is none of those. We don't know who she is, we never see her face.
-
The_Baba — 9 years ago(December 04, 2016 08:12 PM)
Didn't Ziegler say that she was the same girl who OD'd at his party though? Assuming he was speaking the truth.
http://www.imdb.com/list/_OaGg-zdQKo/ -
The_Baba — 9 years ago(December 04, 2016 08:24 PM)
Oh, well he tells Bill that it was the same girl, in the billiard room when he confronts him near the end. But it's never clear if he's telling the entire truth.
http://www.imdb.com/list/_OaGg-zdQKo/ -
Badlands1 — 9 years ago(December 10, 2016 10:24 AM)
You yourself admitted you re-watched the movie "but didn't get very far" So now you're trying to pass negative judgement when you never even finished the film, or plot??
SPOILERS*
Ziegler said at the end; they did not kill the girl at the party it was set up to look like that to shock Bill into never revealing their secret underworld.
She OD'd because she was a junkie, Ziegler said the police found her in her apartment with the door locked from the inside, it could have been the underworld people it could have been her. Either way she was the same girl from the beginning party. -
Melton1 — 4 months ago(November 19, 2025 07:39 AM)
It’s deliberately ambiguous.
Mandy has a much more ‘butch’ physique than the girl at the party, who is a waif-like model who could blow over in a strong wind. Mandy is broader, more plump, and with bigger tits - as we see in Ziegler’s bathroom and the morgue.
The fact that all of the many prominent female characters are red-heads is also part of the ‘blurring’ Kubrick wanted in this Dream Story. -
Belle2Ca — 1 month ago(February 11, 2026 10:34 PM)
Yes true but that's because the girl at the party was a different actress in real life…the character is most likely played by 2 different actress yes…so of course it's not going to match her exact body type.
Also, the writer probably didn't want to make it to obvious it was Mandy during the Party scene.
Remember, Zeigler confesses to Bill towards the end of the movie that he was at the party that night and that the girl at the party was in fact Mandy.
The whole "Sacrifice" scene was staged in order to scare Bill into not telling anyone about about what he saw that night. Mandy wasn't murdered she just died from a drug overdose… similar to how she overdosed earlier in the film and almost died.
I also think Zeigler is really supposed to be the cult leader in the Red Cloak as well… If you notice the way the light was shining on the pool table in that scene and the way he was tapping the pool balls looked very similar to the way "Red Cloak" was tapping his stick during the party scene….he also admits to Bill that he was the one who had him followed.
However, of course we know they were both different actors in real life! -
Melton1 — 1 month ago(February 12, 2026 12:15 AM)
Regarding the dead woman, it’s purposefully inconclusive, we’re supposed to be unsure of what to believe, and Ziegler is not trustworthy.
Ziegler is definitely not Red Cloak as their voices are totally different. -
Belle2Ca — 1 month ago(February 12, 2026 11:15 PM)
Yes well I guess it's possible Ziegler was lying about Mandy… maybe it's supposed to be up to the viewer, I personally think the dead women at the at the party was Mandy.
Regarding Ziegler's voice being different than the Red Cloak guy, the voices ae different of course because as I said in my last post they are played by different actors as they wouldn't want to make it obvious who it was during the Masked Ball scene…It's very possible Ziegler could have been disguising his voice on purpose or using a voice changer device under his mask or costume. -
Melton1 — 1 month ago(February 13, 2026 12:15 AM)
It's very possible Ziegler could have been disguising his voice on purpose or using a voice changer device under his mask or costume.
No, Ziegler is not putting on an English accent and using a voice conversion device
He’s just one of many perverted elites that attended the party. -
Belle2Ca — 4 weeks ago(March 03, 2026 11:29 PM)
It is very easy to find devices that can make your voice have different accents…I'm not the only one who believes that Ziegler was the Red Cloak…do some research online about it there are many different theories on it.
As I mentioned before, watch the scene carefully the way the light shines on him when he is tapping the pool balls on the table and rewatch the Masked Ball scene. It is done the exact same way…there is a reason for that scene IMHO