It is apparent that after sifting through posts on this board, many blithering idiots complain about nudity/sex/graphic-
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — Y Tu Mamá También
lady_of_england — 15 years ago(May 17, 2010 09:45 AM)
It is apparent that after sifting through posts on this board, many blithering idiots complain about nudity/sex/graphic-ness (for want of a better word) of this film.
It is an 18 and is to be watched by adults. And there is a CUT and an UNCUT version. I recommend for future reference if you are easily offended by normal human behaviour being represented on films, watch the cut version.
Similarly, you must remember, THIS IS A FILM. You are watching a form of expression, language, art, call it what you want. It is merely showing a representation of human activities and the film makers feel it is imperitive for the storyline, which I agree with. -
monty_106 — 15 years ago(May 17, 2010 04:09 PM)
Absolutely. The sexual scenes were of paramount importance to the telling of the story. To remove them would be to remove a key aspect of the film. If you are not of the right mental age to be able to handle scenes of an adult nature maybe you should not watch films rated 18.
If depiction of human emotion in some way perturbs your sensibilities I pity your ability to learn and develop. -
Flossieandflo — 15 years ago(May 18, 2010 08:17 AM)
I think another point to consider is that it is very obvious from the start of the film that there will be sexual scenes - so even if someone had started watching it without realising they would have good warning about the next 2 hours. If offended then stop watching.
I didn't have a problem with it personally, it was integral to the story as monty 106 says. -
SinisterTwist — 15 years ago(May 21, 2010 08:08 AM)
It always amazes me that some people are so ok with watching gratuitous violence, yet when you show them naked bodies & people having sex, they blanch & complain about it.
Yeah, if the sex is non-consensual or along those lines, then yeah- I can see complaining about it.
But come on people can watch movies like Die Hard where people get thrown off of buildings & not complain about them, yet they don't want to see two people have consensual sex. There's something extremely wrong with that line of thought.
Besides, how hard is it to look up the content ratings before watching a movie? Or look up reviews about the film? -
Mark_Beronte — 15 years ago(June 01, 2010 01:58 AM)
I'm offended the sex scenes were done so poorly in this movie. I was reminded at every sex scene that I was watching a movie, and that these were actors doing a bad job of acting like they were having sex. Someone should tell them it's in and out not up and down.
I know my behavior can be erratic sometimes. -
lady_of_england — 15 years ago(June 13, 2010 09:35 AM)
Exactly. The paramount of the narrative essentially revolved around their sex lives and the journey they get from it, mistakes, friendships etc so to remove the sex scenes would be crucifying the storyline.
Yes Julio and Tenoch were young, daft and inexperienced so they were bad in bad and like nachohater says Luisa tells them so, I mean it lasted- what 30 seconds with Luisa? -
raveoddgrl — 15 years ago(June 17, 2010 09:34 AM)
Lady of England: You are awesome. I was just thinking how truthful your "Benigno didn't do it" post was and here you are again, being brilliant.
OK, enough arse kissing.
I thought the sex in the film was crucial. I thought it was a lovely exploration of sexuality (homo and hetero) and of that really awkward time between teenager and adult. Like most teenagers that believe they are sex gods, Tenoch and Julio are clumsy and awkward. You see this as soon as the film starts and it is not until the very last sex scene that they show a bit of skill.
I also liked how natural the nudity seemed. The script was written delicately enough that I never wondered if the women were being exploited. I never thought the sex seemed like Hollywood sex which is either perfect (simultaneous orgasms with mood music) or played for laughs. All in all, it was the sex that made the movie so perfect for me.
This is a torch song. Touch me and you'll burn. -
lady_of_england — 15 years ago(June 18, 2010 02:59 AM)
Gosh very flattering lol thank you! Its nice to see different views on here but sometimes they are just outrageous so I feel compelled to question them lol.
Had a quick look on your page about what films you posted about.. Good films.. Better than chocolate and But I'm a cheerleader..
Have you seen Imagine Me and You? Loving Annabelle? Lost and Delirious? Other films in that similar genre?
Yeah I agree the sex was definately cruicial to the storyline, and it was more realistic than Hollywood love scenes. -
raveoddgrl — 15 years ago(June 22, 2010 02:18 PM)
Some of my all time favorite films in "that" genre are:
Affinity, Tipping the Velvet, and Fingersmith
Imagine Me and You, Lost and Delirious
Loving Annabelle, Fire, Aimee and Jaguar, The World Unseen
Wow, I'm starting to realize that all my favorite movies in English have a common theme.
This is a torch song. Touch me and you'll burn. -
lady_of_england — 15 years ago(June 22, 2010 03:34 PM)
Yeah same for me, the ones in your list I haven't seen are Fire, Aimee and Jaguar and The World Unseen..
The others.. LOVE EM! Do you identify with that genre? I also just bought the books of Affinity, Tipping the Velvet and Fingersmith but they're quite hard to get into lol.
Yes it would appear you're all time favourite films have a reoccuring theme! lol! Takes one to know one..
Do you watch many forgein films too? -
raveoddgrl — 15 years ago(July 02, 2010 02:52 PM)
Well the first two, Fire and Aimee and Jaguar, are foreign films. Fire is from India and Aimee and Jaguar are from Germany. They are both awesome films but both require a large box of tissue. Especially Aimee and Jaguar, I have a female friend from Germany whose accent is quite similar to one of the leads. I watch A LOT of foreign films.
This is a torch song. Touch me and you'll burn. -
PamBaby — 13 years ago(February 06, 2013 07:09 AM)
LOL. I thought that, too. Especially at the beginning, with the first sex scene. I kept thinking that there was no way the guy would even be in the right place, going by the position of their bodies. That was distracting.
-
LusitanWanderer — 15 years ago(September 19, 2010 10:46 AM)
thumbs up on that!! I watched this film with my 15yo brother and we both loved it.
I feel that sometimes people in North America and Northern Europe have different opinions regarding sex than Southern Europe and Latin America, which is kinda weird since we're all people.
In Portugal I rented the DVD with all the uncensored scenes and it was rated '16 and +' and I've seen much worse and explicit scenes on national tv and it was deemed appropriate for people aged '12 and +'.
I was definitely not bothered by the sex, nor the drugs but the mexican vocabulary required some subtitles
youngsters dont make mistakes, they try new things n besides, brains r overrated! -
tapper101 — 14 years ago(September 23, 2011 02:34 AM)
Scandinavian countries, and Germany, have basically no censorship, so saying northern Europe and North America share the same idea and opinions regarding sex on TV/in films is wrong. We're way more open to it in northern Europe (except the UK perhaps), I would even say we're more open to it than southern Europe and Latin America. In Scandinavia we show full nudity on live television and in films, naked children, sex, cussing, etc. We don't censor anything, ever.. and we don't get offended by mature content either. Just saying.
-
LusitanWanderer — 14 years ago(September 23, 2011 03:26 AM)
yep, I realize I made a mistake when I said 'North America and Northern Europe are different' but I didnt mean to say they are the same.
in America explicit nudity and sex is still a taboo, in Scandinavia it is quite normal, pure and artistic and in latin countries it is faced as dirty/hot and necessary to keep the audience in whatever show: films, telenovelas, theatres, reality shows and tons of shows that are only about sex.
I find it just a tad stupid to use sex as a way to sell everything. it's like they think everybody's a hormone-bursting teenage boy, which judging by the results of the audiences, they are right
maybe someday we can progress and accept nudity as normal and not as solely sex-orientated.
La jeunesse sait ce qu'elle ne veut pas avant de savoir ce qu'elle veut -
There_Will_Be_Plainview — 15 years ago(July 28, 2010 12:02 AM)
I'm 17 and wasn't bothered at all. In fact, I am glad the nudity and sex was done so naturalistic instead of feeling staged. It made the movie feel all the more real. Hollywood often paints pictures of how sex is, and it isn't usually how it is depicted. I credit the film for being frank, but not overly gratuitous. The sex wasn't used to be arousing, but rather to add to the story. In fact, besides for the voice-overs (which I feel didn't work so well), this was a fantastic movie! 8/10
Check out my film reviews:
www.paleyfilms.net