Nola was pregnant…so it was easy for police to solve case
-
Bernerdawg-732-853460 — 12 years ago(July 07, 2013 01:38 PM)
As another post pointed out, the drug dealer's possession of the ring trumped the pregnancy, since "motive doesn't make a case."
I don't think Nola was lying about being pregnant. She spends the entire movie blowing auditions, so either she's not good at
acting (and thus not very good at pretending) or just unlucky; her character isn't written as a manipulator, only one who follows her passions and takes risks.
I think assumptions are made about Nola because she doesn't get the same screen time as Chloe, so judging her motives is trickier. At one point Chris suggests she's just trying to exact some revenge on the Hewitt family, to which she replies by asking if the pledges of love Chris has been making for months are real or not.
It's like she doesn't love him either, and the anger and frustration she displays isn't aroused by unreciprocated love but by the ease which with Chris maintains his "sham" life. I don't think Nola has nearly the guile credited to her. -
-
Ramuna — 12 years ago(September 10, 2013 01:03 AM)
Nola was never pregnant.
The first thing the police will do on a murder victim is to do an autopsy, and one of the many things they checked on female victim was whether she was pregnant or not. There is no chance they would miss that on autopsy. And besides, nothing about pregnancy seemed to be mentioned in the diary.
So obviously, Nola was never pregnant in the first place. -
LovingBooks — 12 years ago(November 08, 2013 12:18 PM)
I agree that Nola was never pregnant.
Did anyone else notice the crazy number of pills she was taking, every time Chris was arguing with her about leaving Chloe, she rifled through an alarming number of bottles, chose one, and took some pills out. I'm pretty safe in saying they weren't vitamins, who thinks of taking a prenatal supplement in the middle of arguing about the course of your life?
She said that she had an abortion when "she was young" and another when she was engaged to Tom. I didn't get the impression from Tom that he was the most loving and affectionate husband material, but I also didn't feel like he was likely to push someone to an abortion.
I think the two of them deserved each other and their lies. -
Missyrocks — 12 years ago(November 12, 2013 06:05 PM)
Interesting. I never thought of her not really being pregnant but I did think it was a huge hole in the plot to not have the pregnancy mentioned in the diary nor the autopsy. And even if she really wasn't pregnant, given she kept the diary, she would've discussed having tTOLD him she was. It's a huge hole in the plot either way. But either way, Chris gets lucky by missing dumping the ring and they have their suspect. But, of course, if the bullets used in the dead drug dealer's murder don't match to the gun in the other crime plus Chris' motive More holes.
This is always a good movie again similar to Crimes and Misdemeanors- luck trumps reprehensible immorality. -
spookyrat1 — 12 years ago(November 18, 2013 01:32 PM)
the bullets dont need to match cause the gun was never found.
Absolutely! That's not an issue at all.
@Missy rocks
And even if she really wasn't pregnant, given she kept the diary, she would've discussed having tTOLD him she was.
I really don't think we can categorically say that.
I'm really not sure whether she was pregnant or not, but what I found really interesting, was that Mrs Eastby's ghost says she was, in the dream sequence.
Who was having the dream? Was it Chris or the police officer? If it was the cop (who comes to work the next morning claiming he's solved the case) you'd have to think that the police were aware that she was pregnant. If it was Chriswell fate again dealt him a lucky hand. -
brit1012000 — 12 years ago(March 07, 2014 01:12 PM)
There were never any bullets, but shot, he used his father-in-law's shotgun to dispatch Nola and Nola's neighbour.
The police have no way to see if shot came out a particular shotgun. Bullets from handguns and rifles are traceable, shot is not. -
Lash125 — 12 years ago(February 16, 2014 01:08 PM)
Why would she necessarily write that she'd told him? Girls keep diaries to express their feelings for future reference, not to give accurate, objective and detailed accounts of everyday life. Maybe she didn't want to admit to herself that her wrecking of Tom's marriage was based on a lie. "I've finally convinced Chris to leave his wife" would be enough for future reference.
-
loisbcuz-1 — 12 years ago(March 14, 2014 09:53 PM)
If she actually was pregnant, she would have mentioned her desperation in her diary and the police would not have been so quick to dismiss him as a murder suspect.
And yes, it probably would have turned up in an autopsy as well.
Her pushy attitude was enough to make you doubt that she was actually pregnant. -
Memento288 — 10 years ago(April 19, 2015 05:16 PM)
Some people are so thick in this world you need to explain EVERYTHING to them in black and white so they understand..
The ring found by the drug dealer threw the police of.. one of the investigators worked it out and then suddenly the drug dealer was found with her ring that he had thrown.. it's a huge analogy about luck, did you not listen to the opening scene where he talks about luck and luck is a major theme through out the movie, he has several conversations about it. He was lucky the ring hits the banister and lucky the drug dealer picked the ring up.. He's LUCKY.
I hate it how people like you exist. -
Mehki_Girl — 10 years ago(May 17, 2015 08:55 PM)
I watched it again most recently and I see now why they would drop it. Our cops would probably not have been so delicate with him in their questioning and would have pursued the angle of him killing her more than they did, but they did suspect him and at least one cop was going to pursue him after figuring out how he did it. I'm going to assume that if he did, they would have checked phone records, more people would have been interviewed (although it was already known they here having an affair). The motive was getting rid of a pesky girlfriend, pregnant or not. The big but for the prosecution would be getting around the ring being found on the junkie - big reasonable doubt that any defense attorney would have gotten him off for and probably big enough that the prosecution would not have gone on. However, but for luck, if they had pursued it, they would have found the cabdriver and the guy he bumped into, and even the hatcheck girl who could have said those were some damned heavy rackets (also no one to have seen him actually using the things that day). It would have been all circumstantial, but maybe, maybe just maybe some prosecutor would think he could get passt all that. It's also all about winning in court and prosecutors don't take on unwinnable cases and so even if they knew in their gut he was guilty, they wouldn't necessarily bring himm to trial or they would take years building a case hoping the circumstantial stuff would override the ring being found on a dead junkie.
http://www.auplod.com/u/dalpuo430da.png -
holatKolnoa — 2 years ago(September 30, 2023 09:44 AM)
Agree. The cops on the scene were utterly distracted when the neighbor Ian was trying to give them his account. They didn't care about facts and piecing together a case.
When you think of garbage, think of Hakeem!
Folks, calm down! This is not the last chopper outta Saigon!
