Why does the guy with hat in bus-stop help Reacher?
-
klm38 — 12 years ago(July 23, 2013 11:32 PM)
Because three words: F.ck the PO-lice
On a serious note though, while its not unreasonable to assume that those folks disliked the cops and helped him out, I still consider it one of the few lazy pieces of writing in an otherwise good movie. It was also a huge coincidence that the motel he chose to stay at overnight turned out to be the crime scene where Sandy was murdered. -
Impulse_TJ16 — 12 years ago(July 24, 2013 11:00 AM)
Huh? Lazy? It wasn't lazy, it was because exactly what someone here said. What you said. Tom, himself, said that he didn't initially "get" the scene when he read it either, but once he saw the group of people at the time he suddenly got why that scene exists. Ask for the second part, what are you talking about? You do know they dumped the body at the hotel to frame Reacher, right? It took place outside of Sandy's home and they moved her body to the dumpster at the motel.
You had my curiosity, now you have my attention
http://tinyurl.com/a4havet -
klm38 — 12 years ago(July 24, 2013 12:38 PM)
Ah I didn't catch that body transfer. I was confused when I saw the body at the motel after they showed her just outside her home.
While that getaway scene is quite possible, I just felt like it was too easy/convenient for Tom to get away like that. But I suppose if its possible in real life, then there's no harm in using it in a movie plot. -
Impulse_TJ16 — 12 years ago(July 24, 2013 12:43 PM)
All is well my friend, just wanted to clear the confusion up for you. If I sounded irritated I'm sorry about that.
You had my curiosity, now you have my attention
http://tinyurl.com/a4havet -
robinstigator — 12 years ago(July 29, 2013 08:32 AM)
Because this movie sucks and they added that scene to let us know that Jack Reacher is cool with black folks, to make us not worry too much about how the one black cop is the one that is betraying everything. Trying to hide the subtle racism with not-so-subtle good black man
-
paileshalai — 12 years ago(August 15, 2013 06:20 AM)
During the film there seemed to be a community theme, with a lot of shots of the Pennsylvania skyline, suburbs, and many references to baseball and Duvall's character has a scene with Reacher where they mention something about the Yankees. The guy that helped him at the bus stop also had a hat with P on it which looked like a local baseball teams cap. It seems that this was continuing the theme of a tight community where people look out for each other. I also agree with the fact that it appeared to be a 'poor, urban, black' population which may hint at their dislike for the police.
But thats just my theory. -
Impulse_TJ16 — 12 years ago(September 14, 2013 04:44 PM)
What kind of foolishness? All films need some kind of humor, or is your life so soulless that you don't have humor in your every day life?
You had my curiosity, now you have my attention
http://tinyurl.com/a4havet -
quincee33 — 9 years ago(June 17, 2016 04:46 AM)
That particular hat looked like the P from University of Pennsylvania which is an ivy League school That's in Philadelphia in the same state . However, it was dark, and I really only seen the movie once. just looked like the P from Penn not from the Pittsburgh Pirates which would have a bright yellow P However, these days there are all kinds of " 3rd jerseys" " 3rd hat's" " vintage uniforms" ect. Hope that helps.
-
dbre — 12 years ago(October 04, 2013 03:00 PM)
I thought that scene was poignant social commentary. Hollywood was trying to send a message to the powers that be that they believe common folk are no longer on their side.
What is interesting is
that the instinct of the people turned out to be right considering it was the dirty cop that was trying to catch him. If he had, Reacher would be dead. So the message is: trust the instincts of the general public. They can sense who is good and evil -
transmentalist — 12 years ago(October 08, 2013 10:06 PM)
I suggested this in another thread when the idea was still sort of coalescing in my head.
In the earlier scene, Reacher explains what he's come to understand about how people of America aren't truly "free."
He also goes on about situational/tactical awareness.
It's therefore thematically and logically consistent for Reacher to abandon his car in exactly the part of town where he knows people DON'T trust the police, and ARE likely to help him, especially if he presents himself as cool and collected, the authority-resisting rogue rather than the frantic fleeing felon.
In other words, he was smart enough to seek shelter among people he knew would protect him.
He would not, for example, have sought shelter with the two earlier posters who claim they would not have helped him, because they most likely don't live in those neighborhoods, taking those buses, getting hassled by those cops. -
kkarma2 — 12 years ago(October 20, 2013 03:00 PM)
This is probably the best answer.
I did not know the answer and I thought it was stupid.
Think about it someone like Tom Cruise walking up to them.
What he does is cool. he looks them straight in the eye he was saying I am going to trust you guys that it because he knows they know the police are dirty.
He looks at them and they look at him from the care and the way he leaves the car its like taking refuge and they just react to that.
A rapist would not have the guts to do that only an innocent man or someone who has not done such a crime like trying to escape a ticket.