More than you think **Spoilers**
-
KawaiiKiwi — 10 years ago(February 29, 2016 08:31 PM)
That's an interesting theory and the split personality did come across my mind during the film, but I think that's giving too much credit to the movie I don't think that's what the director intended at all, but it would have made a better film if implemented correctly.
-
bigfoot_18 — 10 years ago(February 29, 2016 08:39 PM)
Like I said before, I believe the original script was probably written as this split personality thing, but during the process it got changed to a more classic horror film. All of the scares were just thrown in, with very little of it being a part of the story.
I personally think that either in editing, or during filming the movie was changed, and that is why it is not only bad, but has all of these other elements in there. -
nikosva — 10 years ago(March 22, 2016 10:49 AM)
Your theory helped me understand more things about the movie but you take Aiden's part for granted (australian journalist). Your theory gave me two alternative theories about Aiden
A) As you said he really was a journalist and took her photo in the woods (although I don't remember him taking a picture of her).
B) She insists to go look in the woods for her "sister". The doctor couldn't stop her (as her "husband" he insisted she shouldn't go) or believes that would be a way for her to maybe face her demons / consider dead her "alter ego" and get over her double personality. So, Aiden is an associate of her therapist/husband, sent with her to protect her and take notes (recordings) of her reactions/thoughts for further treatment He already has her photo in his phone (from her therapist i guess).
He gave me the impression he knew there was something wrong with her from the beginning. He lied to her a lot about his brother. The way he was staring at her tent before he fell asleep (except if he wanted to rape her, lol). He "assumed" there should be a radio in the cabin he found "by chance"! He told her Jess was in the basement because he knew that was what she needed to hear and save his ass as well. However, i don't know if they really were lost in the woods as he knew where the cabin was.
Anyway, very confusing film. And if your theory is right, the ghosts should be just urban legends combined with personal demons, visible only to her, cause she had issues. Then what was the final scene with the guide? What did he really see? Probably nothing visible to others. He was superstitious, a believer, and saw what he saw! Or he maybe realized that Aiden was dead or missing since he never showed up!
"Worst/Best movie EVER!"
posts
are science fiction and should be deleted! -
bigfoot_18 — 10 years ago(March 23, 2016 01:07 PM)
I like your description of Aiden better. He definitely does not make much sense in the movie. I like the idea that he was placed by the husband/therapist as a protector and makes much more sense.
The guide at the end falls in line. The guide does not know Jess and the twin is the same. He ends up losing Jess and thinks she is dead in the forest. As a guide, he is of course sad because he left her there. After everyone leaves at the end, he is alone in the forest which makes him fear his sadness. He sees the split that was left behind as a spirit because he feels guilty for her death. Before this, he had no sadness so that us why he survived the forest until now. -
nikosva — 10 years ago(March 24, 2016 04:34 AM)
Very good pointbut only if he really didn't know about the split-personality condition of Jess the second time he gets there. However, he arrives with the therapist/husband and the police (if i recall), so I guess he should be now aware of the situation!
But if he knew, he should see Aiden's "ghost" and not Sarah's. Aiden is now the missing person to cause him sadness and guilt.
"Worst/Best movie EVER!"
posts
are science fiction and should be deleted! -
Pedro_MGA — 10 years ago(March 22, 2016 05:56 PM)
if this is true then the movie just made some sort of sense.
thanks!
http://trakt.tv/users/pedro -
disciple_of_sauron — 10 years ago(March 23, 2016 05:29 AM)
Hello. I watched the movie last night (mainly because I like Natalie Dormer) and enjoyed it though it was pretty confusing nd the ending kinda sucked. Your theory actually made me enjoy it a lot more afterward as it cleared a lot of the confusion. If only the director/writers would've made these things more clearbut then I guess we would've had a very good movie instead of just an ok one. Thanks for your effort though one thing is still making me scratch my head.
If a lot of what happened to the Sara personality in the forest was in Jess's head, how do you interpret the cabin scene towards the end ? Did she, Jess as Sara, kill Aiden, then left for her campsite/tent and when the basement episode was over in her head, she just awoke as Jess? Really confusing, that bit. -
kadeskiss — 9 years ago(April 13, 2016 11:56 PM)
Maybe Aidan wasn't real?
Aidan might have been a part of Sara/Jess imagination. Which would explain how Sara/Jess could kill him so easily without him putting up much of a struggle,and why she didn't have much blood on her after stabbing him.
[love]
Kades! [/love] -
nikosva — 9 years ago(April 16, 2016 11:28 AM)
Nice thought but after a month, i can't remember if there were any scenes with the guide talking with Aiden (especially when Sara wasn't around)
"Worst/Best movie EVER!"
posts
are science fiction and should be deleted! -
leelost-43-748789 — 9 years ago(April 24, 2016 11:08 AM)
The guide says his name at a couple of points as well. Decent theory. I was thinking something along those lines. The dinner scene at the beginning was kind of surreal and dream like to me. This would have been a much better movie if they could decide between thriller or horror but instead they kind of mashed it together.
-
bigfoot_18 — 9 years ago(April 26, 2016 03:44 PM)
As I said before Aiden is tough to explain. He is seen/known by the guide, so he existed. What was not real was his shady behavior. Well, he could have been a serial killer/rapist but I doubt it. If Aiden is real, then that kind of means Jess killed him in that cabin. If he is a figment, then the guide isn't real and that is hard to explain too.
-
Will1988 — 9 years ago(April 21, 2016 05:22 AM)
I just watched the movie and kind of thought that the Jess / Sara could be the same person, but multiple personalities. OP your theory helps cement that. Thanks! Then again this movie was rather mediocre, so I am not sure if the split personalities was where the producers were trying to go with this film but it is the best theory so far.
-
kaiush — 9 years ago(September 10, 2016 10:49 PM)
If you have to say something like an entire characters storyline was a false reality in order to make your theory work, it's probably not a good theory.
Some clever ideas, for sure, but I think you're overthinking this movie. -
madzooted — 9 years ago(September 10, 2016 11:40 PM)
Sorry, but your theory is invalid. Clearly they are two different people with two entire different lives. I have no idea how you can believe this is a case of split personality disorder, your arguments are invalid and idiotic. Best of luck to you in your travels
-
adouthit-1 — 9 years ago(September 13, 2016 08:13 AM)
You could have saved yourself a lot of time and overthinking if you just payed attention to the end of the movie. Jess comes out and Saras husband asks "Have you seen Sara?" and Jess says "She's not with you?" and he looks toward the forest. Then Jess says "She came for me." Then he says "She knew you were still alive." Then he says "We go back in first thing."
So if it was just one person, that whole exchange (among others in the movie) would make no sense. -
ryansassy1 — 9 years ago(September 18, 2016 11:31 AM)
1)A lot of twins choose different hair colors, styles, etc. especially in adulthood. Nothing "obvious" about that being a clue to a split personality.
2) and 3) are pure speculation, not evidence.
4)Hallucinations do not have to be logical. In fact, they usually aren't.
5)Sara has explained before that she and her sister have a sort of psychic connection that lets her know things about Jess that cannot be explained any other way. She had a strong feeling that her sister was in that direction, and it was correct. (you may not believe in the twin psychic connection thing, but plenty of people do. I suggest that you suspend your disbelief in this case, it's central to the plot).
6) and 7) also pure speculation.
I like your interpretation of the poem. There could be others, however.
9)Speculation.
10) Rob (the psychiatrist husband) would have known that his wife had just travelled to Japan and would have commented on it when she brought up her plan to go back to Japan and find her missing sister. In fact, if she had mental health issues and made up this split personality of a twin sister, he would have picked up on it by then. At the very least, he would have objected to this weird second trip and found a way to prevent her from going because it would have just been crazy from his pov.
You also have to remember that it was dark when Jess was coming out of the forest, and her hair color wouldn't have been obvious when she was running toward him. After all, he was fully expecting to see Sara, not Jess, so it would have been an easy mistake to make on the spur of the moment.
And remember, Rob was looking for his wife whom he explicitly named as Sara. He told the search party and presumably the authorities, that his wife, Sara, was in Japan and missing. If Sara was just a split personality of his wife's, he would have named Jess as his wife, wouldn't he?
And in the end, he specifically asks Jess if she had seen Sara. When he realized she hadn't, he said they would be back the next morning to search the forest for Sara.
The guide and Rob both interacted with Sara and referred to her by name. So unless you are suggesting that the guide and Rob both weren't real, your split personality theory can't be valid.
"I'm sorry, but.." is a self-contained lie.
-
blubird-1 — 9 years ago(September 25, 2016 06:38 PM)
No and NO. Its really not hard to understand, it isn't that deep, there were 2 sisters. The trauma of the parents death is the big key to everything and its zero, nada to do with a split personality.and as far as the hair color, twins in real life do this all the time, its called hair dye.
-
jrcjohnny99 — 9 years ago(October 21, 2016 07:46 AM)
Really shouldn't have bothered reading the OP;
practically every point does not make sense if you pay attention to the movie.
Within the first few minutes of the movie we see Sara arrive in Japan; this completely invalidates the rest of the theory.
Do millennials pay so little attention to movies these days or are you just so desperate for every movie you see to be Fight Club?