Which is the best silent hill?
-
Henkm — 19 years ago(July 10, 2006 12:16 AM)
Is there not another collection coming up soon I read it somewhere(Silent Hill complete Set this one is called) and that one would include all Silent hill titles which mean SH1 aswell strange that they release this one know and not before collection.
Anyway the one I think is best is SH1 with SH2 and SH3 close seconds like most people I think SH4 was little of a disappointment I liked some of the new stuff but it was badly inplanted in the game. -
HeavenlyC79 — 19 years ago(July 14, 2006 01:12 AM)
- Silent Hill 3
- Silent Hill 2
- Silent Hill
- Silent Hill 4 the Room
"I'm going to The Fourth World"
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=19890263
-
jajr-1 — 19 years ago(August 11, 2006 02:41 PM)
Silent Hill 1 is pure nostalgia to me. Silent Hill 2 was merely extremely depressing (went through a breakup during the week I played this back in 2001). Silent Hill 3 was just incredibly scary. I never got around to playing the 4th, but I saw itit just ranked in at creepy.
-
C-Burns — 19 years ago(October 23, 2006 04:13 AM)
Just finished re-playing the series in order (as you do
and I have to say I'm with HotChip and solid-12 on this one. I'd say:
1 Silent Hill 2
2 Silent Hill 4
3 Silent Hill 1
4 Silent Hill 3
"2" is just a masterpiece and I really enjoyed "4", I can see what they were trying to do now and I liked the combat system, the spooky ghosts and the fact that you had to cope with hauntings in your apartment. Also really liked Cynthia and Eileen's alternate costumes
"1" has a great story and the sirens (of course!) and some great monsters.
For some reason, "3" just does not hit the right buttons for me (within the context of it still being a bloody good game, very spooky). Not quite sure why Possibly one thing is that it has the "look and feel" of "2" whilst revisiting a lot of the locations of "2" and "1", so just feels like a bit of a rehash.
Anyway, looking forward to "5" (although I'll have to buy a new system to play it on). -
stai567 — 19 years ago(December 04, 2006 04:46 PM)
4 was a great game, but not scary or disturbing by any means. 4's combat is more involved and less limiting, but all of the others have the advantage of the scare factor. 2 was damn scary, 3 was disturbing as hell, 1 was a little creepy.
